Martha [W. Greene] to Frederick Douglass, July 29, 1870

[*Won't you destroy that letter and this?*]
Hannibal Mo. July 29th,
1870

My dear friend,

For the first time in my life a letter from you has brought me more pain than pleasure. I thank you sincerely for being frank with me and telling me the impression you received from mine, and tho' that seemed very strange at first, further thought has made it less so. I think I said, in that letter "it somehow seemed to me as if you were beside me and I could just simply talk along as I chanced to be thinking,"- wether I did say this or not, it was my feeling, and the turn my thought took from having been reading this book of Reade's was a sort of explanation to myself unconsciously

or consciously expressed; of the sort of matter-of-course way in which we have accepted from your hands so many kindnesses, so many practical puttings of yourself in our place—why Frederick when was the time that you have not helped us? I mean now, with money not that higher help which has given to my life a charm. When have you been to us, without leaving a tangible memory? So much so that sometimes I have hesitated to urge you to come, because anybody but you would have deemed me mercenary. So entirely contrary was your interpretation of what I meant by my letter and not having the letter to refer to, not being able to recall, my way of saying it. I am reminded of poor Martin Chuzzlewit , who having money, thought all his friends & everybody were bent on getting it away from him, so the only person he would allow about him was the young girl to whom he gave a small sum during his life for her attendance on him and with the understanding, should leave her nothing at his death. The reasonableness of this feeling in you, reconciles me henceforth to care less for the possession of means, than I have ever done before. I see as I never have before, how difficult it is to distinguish a disinterested friendship -and with this "holding of the mirror up to nature" (I guess that is at the right quotation) my highest content will be to obtain some kind of a standing place like that of the faithful attendant of poor Martin—I am not satisfied not to say more, and yet what more shall I say? You are the friend of all others to whom, to

be under obligations has not been a cross and a trial—the Friend to whom I should have gone first for sympathy or aid, had I been in need - this I could not had I deemed you miserly "hoarding" money—I can't imagine my saying, as you quote that "money can alter genuine affection" &c for I forget having said anything of the kind, it surely is not like me to believe any such thing. Now Frederick, if I have blunderingly mystified what I would be glad to have the power to express simply & truthfully will you please tell me again! I believe what you say, "there can be no sound confidence or friendship in the absence of candor & frankness"—accord me there, whatever else you withhold, and I shall be always gratefully yrs

Martha.Greene, Martha Waldo Brown

Martha Waldo Brown Greene (1820-1902) was the daughter of John and Mary Hodges Brown. She married William Arnold Greene (1822-73) on 9 May 1842. Her husband was engaged in the mercantile business in New York City in 1842-43, when Martha Greene was an officer of the American Anti-Slavery Society. The couple then moved to Worcester, Massachusetts, where they had six children. Martha and Douglass were close friends and remained so after the Civil War. The contents of the letters often addressed private matters such as his relationship with Ottilie Assing. Greene helped Douglass recover from depression after his first wife died in 1882. Martha died in Melrose, Massachusetts, which was the residence of her daughter Martha Greene Sherman. Martha W. Greene to Frederick Douglass, 7 July 1864, 2 August 1865, 22 July 1871 in General Correspondence File, DLC, reel 2, frames 40-42, 138-39, 604-05, FD Papers, DLC; David W. Blight, Frederick Douglass’ Civil War: Keeping Faith in Jubilee (Baton Rouge, 1989), 167; Diedrich, Love across Color Lines, 306, 368; McFeely, Frederick Douglass, 313.

If Wms second letter sent yesterday has not reached you please report immediately

Creator
Greene, Martha Waldo Browne
Date
1870-07-29
Description
FD to Martha W. G[reene]. ALS: General Correspondence File, reel 2, frames 563-67, FD Papers, DLC. Writes about the summertime and gives publishing details for his book, Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass.
Publisher
This document was calendared in the published volume and has not been published in full before.
Repository Collection
Library of Congress, Frederick Douglass Papers: General Correspondence File, reel 2, frames 563-67
Type
Letters
Publication Status
Unpublished