Minor M. Rowan to Frederick Douglass, September 3, 1877
Albany NY Sept 2/77
Hon Fredk Douglass,
My Dear Friend,
I enclose you an Editorial from the Express of our city.
It is a Sample of every days fulmination, direct & indirect, against the administration & many times with personalities against the President. It is one of the stipendiaries of that Clique, headed by Conkling, Cornell & others of a combined aristocracy of office holders who are determined to rule or ruin. Cornell is an egotistical failure. His last resort, is to "rush where angels fear to tread". His last resort is to marterdom, instigated by
by his cowardly manipulations. He has put the chip on his shoulder. Shall he triumph, & the President surrender?
Public sentiment here on either side of the political line is with the President, & growing stronger every day, I am not known to the President or any one of his Cabinet, therefore write you, who have known my Political Course for the past twenty years, to say to President Hayes, in the language of the immortal Sumner, "Stick"
Truly yours,
Minor M. RowanRowan, Minor M.
[Enclosure]
Morning Express.
Saturday, September 1, 1877.
Let Us Consider.
A great deal has been said and is still being said about the action of the Honorable ALONZO B. CORNELLCornell, Alonzo B.
, Naval Officer of the Port of New York, and Chairman of the Republican State Central Committee, in calling, over his own signature, the Republican Convention for this State. Those who appear to be most interested in, or aggrieved by this action on the part of Mr. CORNELL are the Democratic organs, which of course want to encourage anything that looks like a rupture in the Republican party, and newspapers like the New York Times, the Tribune, the Evening Post and Harper's Weekly, which do so out of personal ill-will towards Mr. CORNELL and those who are supposed to have been instrumental in procuring his appointment to the responsible position which he now holds. These latter demand his summary suspension from office on account of the "defiant" attitude which he has assumed toward the administration; the Democratic newspapers content themselves with calling attention to the fact that Mr. CORNELL has apparently violated an order issued by the President, but are, of course, endeavoring to goad the President on to suspending Mr. CORNELL from office.
The Washington correspondent of the New York Times has recently had an interview with the President, in which that amiable and much hand-shaken gentleman alluded to his so-called civil service order, praised it as a good one, spoke of it as extremely popular, and said it would be rigidly enforced against all persons in the service of the government. Being asked if he proposed to enforce ot against the Naval Officer in New York, he declined to be questioned in detail, but repeated his remark that the order was a good one, and would be rigorously enforced. The Times correspondent had, however, other sources of information; and so he telegraphs to his journal that the action of Mr. CORNELL will be considered by the Cabinet at an early day, and that, if the newspaper reports concerning his action are found to be true, he will be suspended from office.
Suspended for what? For simply performing his duty by the party to which he has always belonged, which he has always served, and which placed Mr. HAYES in the Presidential chair! To listen to the ravings of the administration journals about Mr. CORNELL's action, one might imagine that he had proved to be a defaulter, or that he was in league with the smugglers, or that he had shown gross carelessness in the administration of his office. None of these things are so, however. Mr. CORNELL's record is that of an honest and efficient public servant. He is to be suspended, if suspended at all, because his devotion to the Republican party is superior to his devotion to the little clique of busybodies and impracticables whom the President has taken into his confidence, and by whose judgement--or rather lack of judgement--he seems disposed to be guided. Mr. Cornell might readily retain the position of Naval Officer if he would yield something of his political convictions, abandon the positions in the State and
National Republican Committees which were entrusted to him last year, and fall down and worship the new lights of reform, EVARTS, SCHURZ and GEORGE WILLIAM CURTIS. Failing to do these things, determined to pursue a manly course and to discharge, to the best of his ability the trusts confided to him by the Republican party of [?] New York, he is to be punished by the hand of the man for whose election we all labored so earnestly last year!
What law has Mr. CORNELL violated? What resolution of the Republican platform adopted last year has he ignored or refused to be governed by? None whatever. His whole offense consists, first, in his being the friend of Senator CONKLING, and, secondly, in his assertion of self-respect, and his determination to remain faithful to the organization which made him Chairman of the State Committee and a member of the National Executive Committee, rather than to cast his lot with the little clique of hand-shakers and self-styled "reformers."
The order issued by the President on the 22d of June, and which Mr. CORNELL is alleged to have violated, reads as follows: "No officer should be required or permitted to take part in the management of political organizations, caucuses, conventions or political campaigns. This rule is applicable to every part of the civil service. It should be nderstood by every officer of the general government that he is expected to conform his conduct to its requirements." There is no law authorizing the President to issue any such order. There was no precedent for it. In speaking of it, it has frequently been called the "Civil Service Reform order" --but it has nothing whatever to do with civil service reform. It was not demanded or even contemplated by the Convention which nominated Mr. HAYES for President. It is not sustained by the best commitment of
Curtis, Failing to do these things, determined to pursue a manly course and to discharge to the best of his ability the trusts confided to him by the Republican party of the state of New York, he is to be punished by the hand of the man for whose election we all labored so earnestly last year!
What law has Mr. Cornell violated? What resolution of the Republican platform adopted last year has he ignored or refused to the governed by? None whatever. His whole offense consists, first, in his being the friend of the Senator CONKLING, and, secondly, in his assertion of self-respect, and his determination to remain faithful to the organization which made him Chairman of the State Committee and a member of the National Executive Committee, rather than to cast his lot with the little clique of hand-shakers and self-styled "reformers."
The order issues by the President on the 22nd of June and which Mr. Cornell is alleged to have violated, reads as follows: "No officer should be required or permitted to take part in the management of political organizations, caucuses, conventions or political campaigns. This rule is applicable to every part of the civil service. It should be understood by every officer of the general government that he is expected to conform his conduct to its requirements." there is no law authorizing the President to issue any such order. There was no precedent for it. In speaking of it, it has frequently been called the "Civil Service Reform Order" - but it has nothing whatever to do with civil service reform. It was not demanded or even contemplated by the Convention which nominated Mr. Hayes for President. I is not sustained by the best sentiment of the party. It is simply an unwarrantable and arbitrary interference with the rights of a class of citizens who are peculiarly interested in public affairs, most of whom have obtained positions because they have shown such interest. It is an attempt to disfranchise almost an hundred thousand of the men who are best fitted, by inclination and experience, to do with the politics of the country. It is an illegal, and, as we believe, even an unconstitutional edict, prohibiting certain citizens from enjoying the rights and certain citizens from enjoying the rights and privileges which are freely accorded to others. It is a sham and a fraud; it comes to us in the name of civil service reform, but was in reality intended only to reach a certain class of officials of whom the administration is jealous.
There are some who hold that it would be a breach of political fidelity to oppose this order, because a Republican President issued it. We are not among that number. Outside of the party platform - and the order in question is outside of it - the President has no kore right or authority to commit the party to a given policy or principle, or to force a policy or principle upon his party, than the humblest member of the organization. We, as republicans, are under no obligation to stand by and applaud every act of the President. We are under no obligation to remain quiet and say nothing concerning acts which we believe to be injurious in their nature, through fear of disturbing the "harmony of the party." We rest under no injunction, as Republicans of the State of New York, casting half a million votes, restraining us from condemning in positive and outspoken language such acts of the administration as seem to us likely to be productive of evil. The time is approaching when we will be called upon either to indorse the administration without reservation, to keep silent, after the manner of the Maine Republicans, or to speak up plainly, as becomes the Republicans of the Empire State, praising where praise has been earned, and condemning fearlessly such acts as do not command themselves to the judgement. We trust that our State Convention will not be one of the wishy-washy kind. Let it speak out plainly, one way or the other.
