Meeting of the Bristol County Anti-slavery Society, New Bedford, Massachusetts, June 21, 1843

On the second day of the Bristol County Anti-Slavery Convention in New Bedford's Town HallTown Hall, New Bedford, Massachusetts

, Douglass took more time to discuss the resolution offered the evening before that no abolitionists could support any political party that supported the Constitution in its current support of slavery. Discussion of this resolution continued in both the morning and afternoon sessions and seems to have been adopted in the end. See also , June 30, 1843 (p. 2, c. 5-6 and p. 3, c. 1-3) and Lampe, , (2012), 172.

New Bedford , 28 June 1843 (p. 1, c.1-3).

BRISTOL CO. ANTI SLAVERY CONVENTIONBristol County Anti-Slavery Society, New Bedford, Massachusetts

.

WEDNESDAY, June 21.

The Convention assembled at 9 o’clock. Mr Jno. BaileyBailey, John

John Bailey (1788-1883), a watchmaker and jeweler, was a Quaker and longtime abolitionist in the New Bedford area. In 1843 he served as vice president of the Bristol County Anti-Slavery Society, and in the 1850s as the vice president of the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society. In 1854 Bailey and other New Bedford abolitionists launched two antislavery newspapers, the Pathfinder and the People's Press. Lib., 16 June 1843; Ellis, New Bedford, 527-28; Frederick Douglass, "Reminiscences," Cosmopolitan, 7:376-82 (August 1889); Merrill and Ruchames, Garrison Letters, 3:274-75.
, the first Vice Preseident, in the Chair. The Resolution declaring that no consistent abolitionist can sustain either the whigWhig Party

, democraticDemocratic Party

, or LibertyLiberty Party

The Liberty party was organized on 1 April 1840 in Albany, New York. The central principle of this third party was the abolition of slavery. Specific proposals included abolishing slavery in the District of Columbia, ending Jim Crow practices, and opposing the colonization movement. Whereas prominent antislavery figures such as Myron Holley, Gerrit Smith, Joshua Leavitt, and William Goodell all supported the creation of a political party dedicated to antislavery principles, some abolitionists--most notably William Lloyd Garrison and his followers--disapproved of the move to political action. Garrisonians argued that a separate party would divide rather than unite abolitionists. Drawing a large portion of its support from New York, the Liberty party nonetheless persevered for several years. By the 1848 presidential election, however, most Liberty party members had moved to the newly formed Free Soil party. A small faction led by Gerrit Smith retained much of the Liberty party's platform under the name of the Radical Abolition party. Alan M. Kraut, "The Forgotten Reformers: A Profile of Third Party Abolitionists in Antebellum New York," in Antislavery Reconsidered: New Perspectives on the Abolitionists, ed. Lewis Perry and Michael Fellman (Baton Rouge, La., 1979), 119-45; Sewell, Ballots for Freedom, 43-47, 152-69, 285-87.
party, being under consideration at the adjournment, and was again taken up and discussed during the whole forenoon.

Mr S. S. FosterFoster, Stephen Symonds

Born in Canterbury, New Hampshire, radical abolitionist Stephen Symonds Foster (1809-81) studied at Dartmouth College. In 1837, a year before his graduation, he helped to organize the New Hampshire Young Men's Anti-Slavery Society. Foster briefly attended Union Theological Seminary in New York, but by 1839 he had repudiated the ministry. He developed his criticisms of American churches most fully in The Brotherhood of Thieves; or, A True Picture of the American Church Clergy (1843). His practice of interrupting a church service to speak out against complicity with slavery frequently provoked violent reaction. While Foster and his wife, Abby Kelley, whom he married in 1815, were agents for the American Anti-Slavery Society for nearly twenty years, their relationship with the Garrisonians was at best one of strained cooperation. Although Foster believed that the Constitution was a proslavery document, he periodically dabbled in politics. In 1843-44 he endorsed the Liberty party. In the late 1850s, having altered his view of the nature of the Constitution, Foster sought to establish a disunion party "whose avowed aim. . .[would] be the overthrow of the government. . .& whose will. . .[would] be expressed through the ballot box." In the mid-1850s he also argued in favor of slave rebellion in his Revolution the Only Remedy for Slavery (1855). A proponent of distributing land to the freedmen, Foster was disappointed with federal Reconstruction policies. He devoted the last years of his life to agitating on behalf of temperance and women's rights. Parker Pillsbury, Acts of the Anti-Slavery Apostles (Concord, N.H., 1883), 123-55; Lillie B. Chace Wyman, "Reminiscences of Two Abolitionists," New England Magazine, 27:536-50 (January 1903); Parker Pillsbury, "Stephen Symonds Foster,'' Granite Monthly, 5:369-75 (August 1882); Jane H. Pease and William H. Pease, Bound with Them in Chains: A Biographical History of the Antislavery Movement (Westport, Conn., 1972), 191-217; Louis Filler, "Parker Pillsbury: An Anti-Slavery Apostle," NEQ, 19:315-37 (September 1946); ACAB, 2:514-15; NCAB, 2:328-29; DAB, 6:558-59.
advocated the resolution, and in regard to the Constitution of the United States maintained that no individual was bound to abide by it so far as it related to Slavery. On the non-resistance principles, of course they were not bound by it, for they denied the authority of human governments. The laws of God were paramount to all human regulations, and when the latter came in conflict with them, the latter must be disregarded. Further than this, if an individual were called upon to take an oath of allegiance to the Constitution, he might make exceptions to the two articles relating to slavery—support the rest but repudiate these. On this ground a party might be organized, declaring as its fundamental doctrine, the repudiation of the objectionable articles and its adhesion to the rest of the Constitution. He wanted to see a Workingmen's Party, or a free labor party organized at the North of this ground. The whigs and Democrats were alike sick of their present associations [Mr F. is very much mistaken here or else we are,] and a powerful party on those principles might be organized before the next Presidential election. In relation to the Liberty Party, Mr F. said it was worse than either of the political parties, more hypocritical, more corrupt, because false to its professions.—Christianity should be purer than politics, but the Liberty Party took Slavery by the hand on the Church while it refused to support it in the State. Mr PIERPONTPierpont, John

John Pierpont (1785-1866) was a poet and an activist Unitarian minister of Boston’s Hollis Street Church from 1819 to 1845. Douglass quoted Pierpont’s work in many speeches and writings and published this poem, composed in 1839, in the first issue of the North Star. He misquoted a line from the “The Fugitive Slave’s Apostrophe to the North Star” in a lecture to the New Lyceum in Manchester, New Hampshire, on 24 January 1854. Pierpont also appeared with Douglass and many luminaries of the abolitionist movement at the well-publicized fourteenth anniversary meeting of the American Anti-Slavery Society on 9 May 1848 at the Broadway Tabernacle in New York City. NS, 3 December 1847; New York Daily Tribune, 9 May 1848; NASS, 11 May 1848; John Pierpont, The Anti-Slavery Poems of John Pierpont (Boston, 1843), 29-33; DAB, 14:586-87.
said that he could not support the Constitution of the United States. Before he would swear to support it, he would suffer bonds and imprisonment, nay, he would lay down his neck upon th eblock. In regard to Mr Foster's position that an individual might make exceptions to the objectionable articles and swear to support the rest, Mr P. said he was not clear how it could be done. He did not swear as he understood the oath, but as the people of the United States, understood it. He might tell the magistrate how he understood the oath, but he could not make the people understand how he understood it. Foster—But suppose the people do understand, are you free to take it? Mr Pierpont—Most certainly. Mr F.—The people will understand it, if this ground be the fundamental doctrine of a party. Mr P—Let the Liberty party take that ground. Foster—But they do not do it; they will not do it; the Democratic party would sooner do it than the Liberty party. Mr F. said he desired to warn his friends against the whig party; that party was their bitterest enemy; it affected to be friendly to Anti Slavery whenever it could make political capital out of it, but its friendship want no farther. The Democratic party had been consistent, it had guaranteed slavery, and it stood by its pledge, and he honored it for its consistency. The whigs had truckled to the Anti-Slavery movement, and he despised them for it. The Democrats were wrong, the whigs wrong. He would trust neither party, but Anti-Slavey had vastly more to expect from Democracy than from whiggism. Mr C. L. REMONDRemond, Charles Lenox

Charles Lenox Remond (1810-73), the first black lecturer hired by any antislavery society, was born in Salem, Massachusetts, to the daughter of a black hero of the American Revolution and a former slave from Curaçao. In his youth, he learned about the horrors of slavery from his father and experienced the segregation and discrimination practiced by Northern whites. In the late 1820s and early 1830s, Remond read David Walker’s Appeal and became acquainted with William Lloyd Garrison, which led him to dedicate his life to abolitionism. Remond became active in reform movements at an early age. A member of the Colored Association of Massachusetts when it merged with the New England Anti-Slavery Society in 1833, he became an officer in the latter organization. He became an agent for the Liberator and joined the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society shortly thereafter. In 1838 he began lecturing for the American Anti-Slavery Society. Both his color and his ability made him a very popular speaker in both the United States and Great Britain, where he attended the World’s Anti-Slavery Convention as a delegate in 1840 in London. Remond was the sole black lecturer for antislavery societies until Frederick Douglass began speaking in 1842. For a time, Remond and Douglass worked the lecture circuit together. Douglass admired Remond, the more experienced speaker, and named a son for him. Remond traveled and lectured in the British Isles for some sixteen months. Upon his return, Remond was employed as a lecture agent by the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society. Through the 1840s, however, Remond remained a steadfast Garrisonian while Douglass began to favor political action to end slavery, and their friendship suffered. Their close association was troubled as a rift between Douglass and Garrison threatened, and in 1852 Remond announced his intention to cancel his subscription to Frederick Douglass' Paper in protest against Douglass's adoption of non-Garrisonian views of the U.S. Constitution. Their goals, however, remained the same, and like Douglass, Remond recruited black soldiers for the Massachusetts Fifty-fourth Infantry Regiment during the Civil War. After the war, just before his death, Remond urged abolitionists to continue their fight by combatting the racial prejudice that persisted in both the North and South after the end of slavery. Illness curtailed his reform activities after the war. Les Wallace, "Charles Lenox Remond: The Lost Prince of Abolitionism," NHB, 40:696-701 (May-June 1977); William E. Ward, "Charles Lenox Remond: Black Abolitionist, 1838-1873" (Ph.D. diss., Clark University, 1977); FDP, 20 May 1852; New York Daily Times, 26 December 1873; NNE, 8 January 1874; Pease and Pease, They Who Would Be Free, 46; NCAB, 2:303; DAB, 15:499-500.
thought it a waste of time to discuss the merits of either party, but he wanted to know Mr F.’s reasons for believing that Anti Slavery had more to expect from the Democracy than whigism. Mr. Foster said he would tell him in one word; the Democrats had sworn to defend it, and and they had not done it; when they could make capital out of it, they were Anti-Slavery and when circumstances required, they were on the other side. Mr F. alluded to the course of John Quincy AdamsAdams, John Quincy

The eldest son of John Adams, John Quincy Adams (1767-1848) served as the American ambassador to the Netherlands, Berlin, Russia, and England during the early years of the Republic. He also held office as U.S. senator from Massachusetts (1803-08), secretary of state in James Monroe's cabinet (1817-25), and president of the United States (1825-29). From 1831 until his death, Adams sat in the U.S. House of Representatives, where he opposed slavery and its extension and fought the gag rule on abolitionist petitions. In late 1831 he made his first anti-slavery speech on the floor of Congress when he introduced fifteen petitions from Pennsylvania Quakers praying for the abolition of slavery and the slave trade in the District of Columbia. Adams also defended a band of captured Africans before the Supreme Court in the Amistad case in 1841. Despite his association with the aboli-tionist cause, Adams said that he personally favored ending only the slave trade. Samuel F. Bemis, John Quincy Adams and the Union (New York, 1956); Leonard L. Richards, The Life and Times of Congressman John Quincy Adams (New York, 1986); Paul C. Nagel, John Quincy Adams: A Public Life, a Private Life (New York, 1997).
, for whom, he said, he had no respect as an Anti-Slavery man, but on the contrary considered him as one of the most dangerous enemies of universal freedom. The debate was continuted by Mr Pierpont, F. Douglas, E SmithSmith, E.

, and others.
Mr Henry JohnsonJohnson, Henry

defended the Liberty party with a good deal of energy, but the opponents of the party gave pretty conclusive evidence against it, and the resolution was finally passed with but one voice in the negative. Whereupon the Convention adjourned until 2 o’clock P. M.

AFTERNOON SESSION. The Convention assembled at 2 o’clock, Dr Sisson, of Westport in the Chair. On motion of Mr Quincy, leave was given Mr Joseph FullerFuller, Joseph

, of Providence, to relate the narrative of his own experience as a slave. Mr F. is a citizen. At the time of his father's death, who was then in Virginia, being but a child he was claimed as a slave, and actually held in slavery many years, until he proved his right to freedom, by proving himself of white descent, through the evidence of his mother and a brother who resided at the North. At the conclusion of his story Mr Quincy made a few remarks, arguing that the facts just stated were a sufficient refutation of the allegation that the North had nothing to do with slavery.

The resolution relative to the Church and Clergy was taken up, and Mr Spear spoke in its support. He wished it to be understood that this was not an anti-Church or anti-Clergy meeting, but a meeting to all the obstacles in the way of emancipation. It opposed the Church and Clergy no farther than the Church and Clergy were corrupt and allied with slavery. Mr. P. R. Russell now rose to offer a resolution. [The resolution related to the divine appointment of the ministry, and denounced those who denied this doctrine. We have not a copy of the Resolution and are therefore unable to give it at length.] Mr. Quincy objected to the reception of the resolution, as there was one resolution already before the Convention, unless Mr Russell offered it as an amendment to that resolution, in which case it would be in order. Mr Foster wished it to be remembered that the question of the divine appointment of the ministry had been dragged before the Convention, not by him or his friends, but by their accuser. Mr Russell refused to offer his resolution as an amentment, but insisted upon discussing it. Mr. Quincy and others maintained that order must be preserved. This question had not been brought before the Convention. It was not now before the Convention, and could not be dicussed under the pending resolution, and he called upon the President to enforce the rules. If Mr R. would move his resolution as an amendment, thn the question would come up fairly, and he and his friends would meet it. He wished it to be distinctly understood, that if the question were not discussed, it was not because the Convention were to its introduction. Mr Russell said the question had been brought up in Boston and elsewhere by Mr Foster, and he was proceeding to go into the past history of the Anti-Slavery movement, and to show that it had abandoned its original platform, when he was again called to order. Mr Quincy again invited him to present his resolution, but Mr R. declined, and said he was discussing the resolution on the table. By general consent he was permitted to proceed. Mr R’s remarks were made up principally of a historical sketch of what he considered a gradual abandonment of th platform of the old organization. He alluded to the Woman’s Rights question—the non-resistance doctrine—and now, said he, another crisis has arrived—the Divinity of the Church is excerated, and it is declared that the ministry must be swept by the board before slavery can be abolished. The introduction of these matters were an abandonment of Anti Slavery ground. In regard to the resolution before the Convention, he should only object to that part of it which declared the Church and Clergy to be “almost universally” pro slavery. This he held was untrue. The denunciation was too sweeping.—Discrimination should be made between the precious and the vile—the gold and the dross, and the what should not be torn up with the tares. With this exception he approved the resolution. The Church and the Clergy were not “almost universally” pro-slavery. They had done much for the cause of the slave, and we should be grateful for what they had done.

Mr Quincy maintained that the resolution was true.—The great mass of the Clergy and the great body of the Church were the apologists of slavery. There might be here and there an exception, but the exceptions were so few, that they did not invalidate the general correctness of the position of the resolution. In regard to the gratitude due the Clergy for what they had done, Mr Quincy said they had done no more than their duty.— They had sued out of the chancery of Heaven the special privilege of extirpating sin—it was their office—they had taken it upon themselves, and he would no more thank them than he would his washer-woman or chimney-sweep. Mr Russell rejoined in a few remarks, when Mr C. L. Remond took the floor and made a long and eloquent speech in support of the resolution. If he had any objection, he said, to it, it was that it did not go far enough. He disclaimed all hostility to the Church or Clergy any father than they were hostile to Christianity. Against the Church, the Clergy he made no warfare; it was only against the Pro-slavery Church and the pro-slavery Clergy, and these he maintained had o connection with Christianity or Christ with them.—Mr R. continued his remarks, showing the connection of the Churh with the slave system—its silence upon its abominations—its treatment of the colored race, and concluded amid the plaudits of the audience. Mr Rusell remarked that he was glad to find the opposition the church went no farther than its corruptions. In this warfare he bade them God speed. But he understood that Mr. Forster opposed the Church, as the Church, and not its corruptions alone. Mr Foster opposed the Church, as the Church and not its corruptions alone. Mr Foster denied that he had ever uttered a word against the Church of Christ. The debate was continued, but without much interest further, until the hours of adjournment.

EVENING SESSION. The Convention re-assembled at 7 1 2 o’clock. The resolution relating to the Church was again taken up, and Mr Foster spoke at length in its support. His remarks were strong and occasionally eloquent, though less violent than on some former occasions. He also discussed the connection of slavery with the State, and denounced in the severest terms the political parties of the country, which, he endeavored to show, were wedded to slavery and sworn to its support. He was followed by Mr Russell, who endeavored to make some defense of the Church and the Clergy. After some further scattering speeches, the resolution was adopted, without debate; the usual votes of thanks were passed, and the Convention, at about 10 o’clock, adjourned

, That if it be a fact, that the people need to be enlightened as to the physical, moral and intellectual condition of the slaves in our contry, or the moral effects of the slave system upon the slave-holder and the country at large, it proves to a demonstration that our spiritual guides, as the clergy are called; are —“dumb dogs that will not bark”—gross hypocrites, and wolves in sheep’s clothing.

, That the outrage and insults which are heaped upon the heads of the people of the free States by those of the slave States; the pecuniary losses with which they have burthened us; the political servitude under which we groan; the change which they have wrought in our national institutions from a Democracy to an Oligarchy; the base services which they require of us, are but a just recompense of our participation in the guilt of slave-holding—and that we should not expect, nor do we deserve, any exemption from these evils, until we have entirely exonerated ourselves, politically and ecclesiastically, from all connection with slavery.

, That the demand of the Southern slave-holders, that we at the North shall not interfere with the peculiar institutions of the South, because they do not concern us, is a demand as impudent as it is arrogant; and that the late doings of the President of the U. S. and his son, in relation to , show that in making it, its authors seek to lay a yoke upon our necks, which they indignantly shake from off their own.

, That this Convention recommend to the abolitionists everywhere, as one efficient means of elevating and improving the condition of the colored people, and thus indirectly giving substantial support to the Anti-Slavery cause, that in all cases when it may be in their power, they obtain as apprentices, and otherwise give employment to, this portion of our neglected and suffering brethren.

The proceedings of the Convention, up to last evening, were marked with general quiet and good order; but on that evening we regretted to notice a disposition to disturb the deliberations of the body, among a portion of the audience near the entrance of the Hall, but there was not extensive disorder, and the adjournment was marked by as much quiet and regularity as usually attend upon the dispersion of large assemblies.

We should not forget to add, that during the afternoon and evening, the Hutchinson Family favored the audience wtih several appropriate pieces of music, and on every occasion were received with the most marked manifestations of gratification and delight.

On Thursday morning, a large number of the Anti-Slavery friends embarked in the steamer for Nantucket, where they propose to hold a series of meetings like those whose proceedings in this place we now bring to a close.

Date
1843-06-21
Description
Douglass discussed the role of political support in the cause of abolition.
Publisher
This document was calendared in the published volume and has not been published in full before.
Repository Collection
New Bedford Register, June 28, 1843 (p 1 c 1)
Type
Speeches
Publication Status
Unpublished