Meeting of The Society of Universal Inquiry and Reform at Lynn, Massachusetts, January 29, 1842.
Following the annual meeting of the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society, Douglass traveled home to Lynn where a four day meeting of the Society of Universal Inquiry and Reform was being held from the 28th-31st of January. The Society had been founded in Ohio only a few months prior in 1842 by John A. Collins and others. A loose coalition of New England Garrisonians and Hicksite Quakers from Ohio and other states in the Midwest, the groups found common ground in condemning Protestant churches' compromises with slavery, belief that the market economy was immoral, a desire for dietary reforms, the belief that the nonresistant principles. However, it was short lived, folding in 1846. At the meeting in 1842, Douglass's presence demonstrated his broadening interest in social reforms beyond abolitionism. The meeting was "fully attended" and attracted healthy interest, though any specific comments he made are not recorded here. Discussion of private property rights and morality occupied much of the meeting. See also, Hamm, , 1842-1846, (1995); Lampe, , (2012), 154.
, February 17, 1843 (p. 4, c. 2-4).
SOCIAL REFORM
Property Meetings at LynnLynn, Massachusetts
.
DEAR GARRISON:
A special meeting of ',' to examine the influence which capital, monopolized as it now is by individuals, associations and governments, exerts upon society and reform, and to inquire into the rightful existence of that principle which allows of individual and absolute ownership in the soil and the products of labor, in contradistinction from the whole human family, was holden in Lynn, on Saturday, Sunday, and Monday, the 28th, 29th, and 30th of January, and continued, by adjournment, through Tuesday and Wednesday evenings, up to Thursday noon. Wm. BassettBassett, William
, of Lynn, one of the Vice-Presidents of the Society, occupied the chair, and Sydney H. GayGay, Sydney Howard
Born in Hingham, Massachusetts, Sydney Howard Gay (1814-88) abandoned the study of law in his father's office to embrace the non-violent principles of Garrisonian abolitionists. After lecturing for the American Anti-Slavery Society in the early 1840s, Gay edited its official New York City-based newspaper, the National Anti-Slavery Standard, from 1844 to 1858. From there he went to work for the New York Tribune, serving as that Republican party paper's managing editor during the Civil War. Gay held the same position at the Chicago Tribune (1868-71) and then devoted most of his energies to writing popular histories and biographies. Raimund Erhard Goerler, "Family, Self, and Anti-Slavery: Sydney Howard Gay and the Abolitionist Commitment" (Ph.D. diss., Case Western Reserve University, 1975); ACAB, 2:618; NCAB, 2:494; DAB, 7:195.
, of Hingham, and J. A. CollinsCollins, John Anderson
John Anderson Collins (1810-c. 1879) of Manchester, Vermont, trained for the Congregational ministry at Middlebury College and Andover Theological Seminary before becoming a general agent for the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society in 1837. In 1840 he toured England, where he became interested in the utopian economic reform plans of Charles Fourier and Robert Owen, which included the abolition of all private property. From 1840 to 1841 Collins edited the Monthly Garland and compiled a book of antislavery songs, Anti-Slavery Pic-Nic. After leading the One Hundred Conventions tour in 1843, he resigned from the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society and founded a short-lived communal farm near Skaneateles, New York. During the 1849 gold rush, Collins migrated to California, where he attempted journalistic and mining enterprises but found little success. Carleton Mabee, Black Freedom: The Nonviolent Abolitionists from 1830 through the Civil War (London, 1970), 76, 80- 82, 88, 112-25, 212, 264, 394; Dorothy Sterling, Ahead of Her Time: Abby Kelley and the Politics of Antislavery (New York, 1991), 103, 136, 158, 177-79; Merrill and Ruchames, Garrison Letters, 2:453-54n; DAB, 4:307-08.
, were appointed Secretaries. The meetings were very fully attended, and the debates were animated and deeply interesting up to the close of the last session. John M. SpearSpear, John M.
,——— CampbellCampbell, Mr.
, C. L. RemondRemond, Charles Lenox
Charles Lenox Remond (1810-73), the first black lecturer hired by any antislavery society, was born in Salem, Massachusetts, to the daughter of a black hero of the American Revolution and a former slave from Curaçao. In his youth, he learned about the horrors of slavery from his father and experienced the segregation and discrimination practiced by Northern whites. In the late 1820s and early 1830s, Remond read David Walker’s Appeal and became acquainted with William Lloyd Garrison, which led him to dedicate his life to abolitionism. Remond became active in reform movements at an early age. A member of the Colored Association of Massachusetts when it merged with the New England Anti-Slavery Society in 1833, he became an officer in the latter organization. He became an agent for the Liberator and joined the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society shortly thereafter. In 1838 he began lecturing for the American Anti-Slavery Society. Both his color and his ability made him a very popular speaker in both the United States and Great Britain, where he attended the World’s Anti-Slavery Convention as a delegate in 1840 in London. Remond was the sole black lecturer for antislavery societies until Frederick Douglass began speaking in 1842. For a time, Remond and Douglass worked the lecture circuit together. Douglass admired Remond, the more experienced speaker, and named a son for him. Remond traveled and lectured in the British Isles for some sixteen months. Upon his return, Remond was employed as a lecture agent by the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society.
Through the 1840s, however, Remond remained a steadfast Garrisonian while Douglass began to favor political action to end slavery, and their friendship suffered. Their close association was troubled as a rift between Douglass and Garrison threatened, and in 1852 Remond announced his intention to cancel his subscription to Frederick Douglass' Paper in protest against Douglass's adoption of non-Garrisonian views of the U.S. Constitution. Their goals, however, remained the same, and like Douglass, Remond recruited black soldiers for the Massachusetts Fifty-fourth Infantry Regiment during the Civil War. After the war, just before his death, Remond urged abolitionists to continue their fight by combatting the racial prejudice that persisted in both the North and South after the end of slavery. Illness curtailed his reform activities after the war. Les Wallace, "Charles Lenox Remond: The Lost Prince of Abolitionism," NHB, 40:696-701 (May-June 1977); William E. Ward, "Charles Lenox Remond: Black Abolitionist, 1838-1873" (Ph.D. diss., Clark University, 1977); FDP, 20 May 1852; New York Daily Times, 26 December 1873; NNE, 8 January 1874; Pease and Pease, They Who Would Be Free, 46; NCAB, 2:303; DAB, 15:499-500.
, Wm. Bassett, Jona. BuffumBuffum, Jonathan
Jonathan Buffum (1793-1868) was a shoemaker, house painter, and merchant in Lynn, Massachusetts. Born and raised a Quaker, he later devoted his religious interests to spiritualism. Buffum was also involved with the public affairs of Lynn; he was the president of the town's first antislavery society and held several town offices. In 1816 he married Hannah Breed, and together they had five children. William Richard Cutter, ed., Genealogical and Personal Memoirs Relating to the Families of Boston and Eastern Massachusetts, 4 vols. (New York, 1908), 3:1616-17.
, Frederick Douglass, Geo. BradburnBradburn, George
Son of a woolens manufacturer in Attleboro, Massachusetts. George Bradburn (1806-80) trained for the Unitarian ministry, but subsequently devoted his energies to championing numerous secular reforms. Bradburn also acted as an agent for the American Anti-Slavery Society in 1839, and he attended the World's Anti-Slavery Convention in 1840. He was not a strict Garrisonian however, opposing all propositions in favor of dissolving the Union and favoring political means to accomplish the abolition of slavery. Bradburn represented Nantucket as a Whig in the state legislature (1839- 42), where he led the successful effort to repeal Massachusetts's antimiscegenation law. In the 1840s he lectured for the (Garrisonians and traveled with Douglass on many occasions. He later joined the Free Soil party and edited two Free Soil newspapers, the Pioneer and Herald of Freedom and the True Democrat. In addition to abolitionism. Bradburn supported women 's rights, temperance, pacifism, and an end to capital punishment. Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society, Eleventh Annual Report: Presented to the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society by its Board of Directors (Boston, 1843 ), 44, 90-91; idem. Twelfth Annual Report: Presented to the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society (Boston. 1844), 34; George Bradburn, A Memorial of George Bradburn, comp. Frances H. Bradburn (Boston, 1883).
, Oliver JohnsonJohnson, Oliver
, James BoyleBoyle, James
James Boyle was born a Roman Catholic in Upper Ontario, but by the early 1820s, he became a Methodist minister noted for his fiery preaching. Throughout the 1820s he served at various churches, including posts in Ohio, Michigan, and upstate New York, where he became acquainted with Charles Grandison Finney. In 1831 the young John Humphrey Noyes heard Boyle in Brattleboro, Vermont. Greatly moved by Boyle’s conviction and oratory, Noyes recommended Boyle for the pastorate of the Free Church in New Haven, Connecticut. Boyle took this position in spring 1833, and he and Noyes became close. Together they developed some of the earliest tenets of perfectionism. In spring 1834 they launched a biweekly periodical, the Perfectionist, to highlight this new religions teaching. Soon, however, they parted ways as Boyle found himself increasingly unable to embrace Noyes’s more radical positions such as the possibility of actual human perfectibility through the removal of any trace of sin. By early 1835 Boyle had complete control of the Perfectionst and proceeded to contest Noyes’s teachings while espousing the free-love creed of Theophilus Gates. In 1836 Boyle left New Haven and moved to Newark, New Jersey, to live closer to Gates. In 1837 he allied himself with William Lloyd Garrison and immediate abolitionism. Boyle then relocated to Ohio, where he served as an antislavery agent and lecturer for the Ohio Anti-Slavery Society and wrote occasional articles for the Liberator. In the 1840s, he became interested in socialism and joined a Fonrierist community in Northampton, Massachusetts. At the same time, he embraced the New Covenant movement, which eschewed all formal religions organization and ritual. Boyle later followed Swedenborgianism and experimented with faith-healing. Lib., 2 August 1839, 31 March 1843; Whitney R. Cross, The Burned-Over District: The Social and Intellectual History of Enthusiastic Religion in Western New York, 1800–1850 (New York, 1950), 189–91; Robert David Thomas, The Man Who Would Be Perfect: John Humphrey Noyes and the Utopian Impulse (Philadelphia, 1977), 43–44, 70–71, 76–77; George Wallingford Noyes, Religious Experience of John Humphrey Noyes, Founder of the Oneida Community (New York, 1923), 59, 165–69, 178–85, 202–07, 253, 255, 298–301.
, Addison DavisDavis, Adddison
, James N. BuffumBuffum, James Needham
James Needham Buffum (1802—82), born of Quaker parents in North Berwick, Maine, spent most of his life in Lynn, Massachusetts, where he amassed considerable wealth as a carpenter, house contractor, real estate speculator, and financier. Dissatisfied with Quaker passivity on reform issues, Buffum was an early convert to Garrisonianism and participated in the campaign to desegregate New England’s public transportation during the early 1840s. From 1845 through 1847 Buffum accompanied Douglass on a lecture tour of Great Britain. He served as treasurer of the Essex County Anti-Slavery Society and vice-president of a Fourierist organization called the Friends of Social Reform. During Reconstruction he was director of Charles Steams’s Laborers’ Homestead and Southern Emigration Society, which bought land in Virginia for resale to freedmen. Chosen a presidential elector in 1868, Buffum served as mayor of Lynn from 1869 to 1825 and was elected to the Massachusetts legislature in 1.873. Garrison and Garrison, Garrison Life, 3 : 324 45. 4: 358; Mabee, Black Freedom, 114, 119—21, 125, 210—11, 221, 225, 250, 342; Merrill and Ruchames, Garrison Letters, 3 : 138n.; Douglass, Life and Times, 251, 259; James M. McPherson, The Struggle for Equality: Abolitionists and the Negro in the Civil War and Reconstruction Princeton, N.J., 1964), 415; Clarence W. Hobbs, Lynn and Surroundings (Lynn, 1886), 141—42; James R. Newhall, Lynn: Her First 250 Years (Lynn, 1880), 133—34; James R. Newhall, History of Lynn, 1864-1893 (Lynn, 1897), 337; Renfrewshire (Scot.) Advertiser, 11 April 1846; Concord (N.H.) Herald of Freedom, 28 November 1845.James Needham Buffum (1807- 87), born of Quaker parents in North Berwick, Maine, spent most of his life in Lynn, Massachusetts, where he amassed considerable wealth as a carpenter, house contractor, real estate speculator, and financier. Dissatisfied with Quaker passivity on reform issues, Buffum was an early convert to Garrisonianism and participated in the campaign to desegregate New England's public transportation during the early 1840s. From 1845 through 1847 Buffum accompanied Douglass on a lecture tour of Great Britain. He served as treasurer of the Essex County Anti-Slavery Society and vice president of a Fourierist organization called Friends of Social Reform. During Reconstruction he was director of Charles Stearns's Laborers' Homestead and Southern Emigration Society, which bought land in Virginia for resale to freedmen. Chosen a presidential elector in 1868, Buffum served as mayor of Lynn from 1869 to 1875 and was elected to the Massachusetts legislature in 1873. Clarence W. Hobbs, Lynn and Surroundings (Lynn, Mass., 1886), 141-42; Garrison and Garrison, William Lloyd Garrison, 3:324- 25, 4:358; Merrill and Ruchames, Garrison Letters, 3:138n; Mabee, Black Freedom, 114, 119- 21, 125, 210-11, 221, 225, 250, 342.
, James P. BoyceBoyce, James, P.
, H. G. WrightWright, H. G.
, of England, Israel BuffumBuffum, Israel
, Mrs. GoveGrove, Mrs.
, Drs. BrownBrown, Dr.
and KittredgeKittredge, Dr.
, Thos. DavisDavis, Thomas
Thomas Davis (1806-95), a jeweler, immigrated to the United States from Ireland in 1817. He represented Providence in the Rhode Island senate as a Democrat from 1845 until 1853, and served on the executive committee of the Rhode Island State Anti-Slavery Society in 1849. In November 1852 Davis was elected to the U.S. House of Representatives, where he served one term. Following a failed attempt at reelection in 1855, he returned to his jewelry business in Providence. After losing three additional bids for a congressional seat, Davis returned to state politics, where he had more success. He served in the Rhode Island senate again in 1877 and 1878, and in the state house of representatives from 1887 until 1890. His wife, Paulina Kellogg Wright Davis, whom he married in 1849, was also a well-known abolitionist and women's-rights activist. NS, 30 November 1849; Washington (D.C.) National Era, 7 April 1853; Benjamin F. Moore, Providence Almanac and Business Directory for the Year 1843 (Providence, 1843 ), 46; BDUSC (online).
, Wm. B. EarleEarle, William B.
, and others, participated in the discussions.
The first day of the Convention was mostly occupied in exposing the evils of the present social arrangements. Soon, however, the debates took a wider range. In urging a reorganization of society, as absolutely indispensable to the imrpovement and elevation of the race, the question very naturally arose—' ' The remainder of Saturday, and all of Sunday, was occupied in the evolution of this question. It was urged, on the one side, that men were the victims of institutions—that they inherited certain characteristics of mind, either favorable or unfavorable to mental or moral development—that they were thrown into virtuous or vicious society, and their minds imperceptibly and gradually, but postively moulded to the institutions around them, as really as was the foot of the female Chinese to the wooden shoe into which it was pressed, and all these under circumstances over which they had no control—that the old theological dogma of the inherent depravity of the race was a libel both on God and man—that the benevolent Creator had established laws, fixed and immutable, which, when obeyed, will bring us into perfect harmony with Him and the whole family of man—that society, as it now exists, is all false, with hardly a redeeming feature in it—that poverty and riches, scarcity and abundance, intelligence and ignorance, tyranny and servility, slavery, war, deception, fraud, disease, and premature death, are the legitimate fruits of the present state of society—that, from the necessity of the social arrangements, our interests cannot be identical, but must be diverse and antagonistical—that if we would better the condition of the people, we must so alter the external arrangements of society, that they shall harmonize with the natural wants and feelings of man. It was argued, on the other and, with great force and beauty, that man was the creator of institutions—that it was his own fault, if he became a victim to them—that his soul was so mysteriously connected with the Infinite, as to enable him, if he desired it, to overcome the influences of society, trample on all human arrangements, and to bring himself into perfect harmony with Divinity. I regret, exceedingly, that notes of the remarks were not taken, that the conversation might be given to the readers of the Liberator.
On Monday, the following brief plan of reorganization was presented, with the view of bringing the subject of capital and its rights more directly before the Convention :—
1. That competition is the legitimate fruit of the present social system.
2. That this system of competition is perpetuated by that principle which allows of individual and absolute ownership of the soil and its products.
3. That the , or equivalent system of exchange, necessarily produces inequality of possessions.
4. That from this inequality of possessions flow the various grades and castes which curse society with mental, moral and physical inequalities.
5. That slavery, war, theft, piracy, and governments of force and violence, are the products of the equivalent and accumulative system.
6. That the fraternity of the human family cannot practically be acknowledged while the system of individual and absolute possession is allowed.
7. That a community of interests and labor will alone supersede the necessity of competition, and all the collateral evils growing out of trade ; as individuals combined together may resist the aggressions of the present false system of society, while a single individual could not ; and thus enable the community to relieve all its members from want, ignorance and degredation.
8. That trade and commerce, the bane of civilization, can be superseded only by the ability of the community to produce every thing essential to its own wants.
9. That three hundred families are necessary to sustain all the agricultural, mechanical, scientific and educational departments of the community.
10. That scientific and mechanical power should be introduced, so as to supersede, as far as possible, the necessity of manual labor.
11. That it is important that the community should be located in a healthy region, and in the heart of a thickly populated country, with good mill privileges.
12. That a large dwelling, with factories, and other buildings, should be erected, with a view to health, taste, convenience and economy.
13. That since the soil, with all its products, is to be regarded as the joint property of the race, it legitimately follows, that the soil occupied by the community, and its products, should be considered the property of the whole family of man.
14. That to render industry attractive, every individual consumer in the community should, so far as health and circumstances will allow, become a producer.
15. That no test for membership should be instituted ; but, when a vacancy is occasioned, any one who desires it should be entitled to enter the community.
16. That every one should be allowed to enjoy his or her own opinion, without proscription.
17. That all force, other than that of mind over mind, should be repudiated.
18. That it should be the object of the community to educate all the faculties of our nature; to secure to each one the highest individual immunity ; to demonstrate to the world, in practice, that a better state of society may exist ; that the excessive toil and the constant anxiety for present and future wants, now imposed upon all, both rich and poor, are unnecessary ; and with a view, ultimately, of bringing society throughout the world into perfect harmony with the nature and wants of man.
19. That by virtue of this combination of interests, and the introduction of labor-saving machinery, labor may be reduced one half or three fourths ; and thus the community might be enabled to sustain a large number of men and women, well supplied with periodicals and publications, who might advocate, without money, and without price, the great principles of reform.
Exceptions were taken to that portion of the report which denies the right of an individual to absolute ownership in the products of his own labor. No one defended the right of individual ownership in the soil, if my memory serves me correctly.
The question of private property occupied the remainder of the Convention. It was argued, by those friendly to individual possession, that appropriation, or the desire to appropriate objects, and to make them, as it were, a part of the individual self, was an attribute natural to man in every stage of society, and in every age of life—that private property is nothing else than the application of man's individuality to external things, or the realization and manifestation of man's individuality to the material world—that mine and thine were written upon the consciousness of every one—that the uncaught fish in the ocean, or the fruit in the pathless forest, must be the property of him by whom they were first taken—that his title to them was complete and absolute, his own, to use and appropriate against the universe—that if the priciple was adopted, that each member of the human family was an equal and joint proprietor of all the products of the earth, it must be apparent, to all discerning minds, that every industrious individual or community would, by these principles, invite hordes of lazy, worthless, starving bipeds, to consume every thing as fast as it was produced—that there could be no protection to any one, in the enjoyment of either the necessaries or comforts of life, against the rapacity of the indolent millions—that private property was the only thing that would allow the gratification of individual taste—that the individual would be swallowed up in the community—and last, but not least, . It was admitted, on all sides, that the present social structure of society was false—that politics were unable to secure permanent relief—and that associating in communities was the only correct and philisophical instrumentality, to bring mankind into a more perfect state of society. It was considered, however, dangerous to strike at the right of individual property ; but that a community, recognizing individual possession and accumulation, and rewarding , , and in the following proportions, would render industry attractive, and would enable the laborers, ultimately, to become capitalists :
Labor should be rewarded, 5-12ths.
Talent " " 4-12ths.
Capital " " 3-12ths.
The property of the community shoud be divided into shares of from 10 to 100 dollars. Small shares should draw a greater per centage than the large shares to protect the laborer. It amounts to this :—The laborer draws about 41 cents for every dollar he earns—the overseers, merchants, clerks, teachers, &c., draw about 33 cents out of every dollar the laborer produces—and the capitalist who does nothing but consume the products of the working man, draws about 25 cents out of every dollar he produces. This is a prominent feature of the system of , an eminent French philosopher. This system has been advocated in this country with considerable success, for the last three years, by Mr. , of New-York. This was no doubt a great advance in the old countries, where the laborer receives but about one-twelfth of the products of his own earnings ; but it occurs to me that it will not satisfy the mass of inquiring, intelligent reformers of this country.
It was urged, on the other hand, that it was most evident, from the harmony and perfection of the laws of the material world—from the wonderful adaptation of means to ends everywhere exhibited—and from the adaptation of the external world to meet the wants and desires of our species—that man was designed for the enjoyment of happiness in the present state of existence—that the first step to the attainment of this happiness is, that he should be guarded in the enjoyment of the necessaries of life, that he might make himself acquainted with the laws and rights of his nature—that whatever necessarily tends to deprive him of this immunity, to throw him out of his natural orbit, to prevent him from cultivating the powers given to him for his own and others' good, and thus to defeat the great end of his existence, is wrong, and should be instantly repudiated—that the soil, like the sun, air and ocean, is the joint and common tenury of the race—that every individual is entitled to enough of each to satisfy his necessities—that man enters the world with certain wants, with physical energies and mind to guide those energies, competent to satisfy those demands—that if he is deprived of the soil from whence spring those things capable of satisfying his necessities, his right to existence is incomplete, and if he lives, it is not by right, but by sufferance—that if every one has an individual and absolute right to the products of his own industry, then no other person has any right to them, and it therefore follows, that the children, the sick, and the lame, and all those unable to produce, have no right to the necessaries of life, and that such, if they are allowed to exist, must be regarded as paupers upon the benevolence and charity of others, and that the great end of man's existence hangs upon the mere contingency of individual capriciousness. It was also urged, that in consequence of this exclusive right to private property, the wealthy few had always been enabled to hold the lives of the masses in their hands—to bring such into subjection, and to make them the mere instruments to the gratification of their selfish passions—that these evils were not the mere accidental abuse of trust granted to property holders, but as necessarily and as legitimately grow out of it, as whips, chains, gags and all the horrors and impurities of the plantation follow the admitted right of one man to chattelise another, or beastly intoxication, with all its concomitant evils, follows the admitted use of alcoholic drinks, or war and violence, from the principle of physical resistence—that exclusive possessions with exchange on the equivalent system, is a great wrong in itself, . It was contended that governments, though ostensibly designed to protect life and person, were, in reality, but an instrument of property for its protection—that cunning and crafty ecclesiastical or political aspirants could, by the aid of wealth, virtually occupy the pulpits, dictate in the halls of legislation, sit upon the bench of justice, preside over literary institutions, govern the press throughout the country, and create a public sentiment in the land that should mirror forth themselves. It was also argued, that if appropriation be an attribute, natural to man, it by no means necessarily followed, that every object appropriated must be the individual and absolute property of the appropriator—that it is as common for the children, before they learn, from the present social structure of society, the necessity of individual property as essential to protect them from want, and from the aggressions of others, to appropriate to themselves or others, certain stars, beautiful clouds, birds or animals, as dolls, hoops or other play things—that if '' may be applied to objects too subtle and common to be converted into substantial property, and yet held in common, may not the goods of the earth, the necessaries of life, be held on the same principle, without doing violence to the attributes of possession and appropriation—that if the doctrine of appropriation be correct, () that principle must be false which will, when carried to its natural and legitimate results, allow, as in Great Britain, only of its inhabitants the privilege of appropriating soil to themselves, and multitudes from appropriating food sufficient to preserve life, but that that must be the correct principle which will allow every individual to appropriate to himself whatever is essential to his wants and comfort, and that will protect the weak, the ignorant and the decrepid from the infringements of the avaricious, or, what is better, will destroy the aliment which feeds and keeps alive the principle of avariciousness.
In answer to the objection urged against a community of interests, that no one would be safe from the invasion of lazy, starving thousands, it was argued that this had ever been the prominent argument urged by tyrants and usurpers, in all countries and ages, as a reason why the people should not have their rights acceded to them ; that there was a universal want of confidence in the integrity and good feeling of the masses ; that whenever their rights and humanity have been partially recognized, the confidence reposed in them has never been abused ; that there is enough produced, ever year, to satisfy the necessities of all, if every one could be allowed to gratify their wants from the general abundance ; that even in the present unsocial, selfish, isolated state of society, there would be no want or degradation, if men would regard the property of the earth as did the children of Israel the manna in the wilderness, 'when they that gathered little had no lack, and they that gathered much had nothing over ;' that if the doctrine be true, that man has a positive and absolute right to the fruits of his own toil, it then follows that the poor and comparatively despised producers would come into possession of the wealth of the globe, and that the rich, wise and refined consumers would be compelled either to labor, beg, or starve ; that it must be evident to the most superficial observer, that gold, silver, houses, lands and stocks, cannot produce either the comforts or the luxuries of life, without the mind, bone and muscle of the producer ; and then, by the principle laid down the opponents, these products cannot become the property of the rich consumers, but of the producers.
The above is a very brief and imperfect sketch of the arguments advanced at the Convention. It has been my aim to state the strongest arguments of both sides fairly.
A committee was appointed to call Conventions to examine this question more at length, to be held in New-England, New-York, and Ohio.
It was the wish of the Convention that you should publish the proceedings of this meeting in the columns of the Liberator. By so doing, you will oblige your sincere friend,
J. A. COLLINS.
Boston, Feb. 9, 1843.
