Seventh Annual Meeting of the Rhode Island Anti-Slavery Society, Providence, November 16-18, 1842 (Herald of Freedom, November 25, 1842)

The Seventh Annual Meeting of the Rhode Island Anti-Slavery Society was held in Providence from November 16-18, 1842. One purpose of this meeting was to decide if the society should cease its efforts "or with renewed strength and zeal, go on," even after the suffrage question had been concluded. Douglass departed his home in Lynn for the convention in poor health and this would affect and limit his participation in Providence. However, he was appointed to the business committee when the meeting commenced on the first day. Later, Douglass presented one speech despite being "under painful affliction of the lungs and at hazard of renewing." This seems to have been the last he participated actively at this convention. Nonetheless, his efforts were judged to have been “the most gentlemanlike” and he continued to build a favorable reputation as a orator.Other speakers at this event were George Latimer, Charles Lenox Remond. See also Lampe, , (2012), 151-152; , December 9, 1842 (p. 3. c. 3-4); Providence (RI) , November 18 1842; Providence (RI) , November 14, 1842.

, November 25, 1842 (p. 2, c. 6-p. 3, c. 1).

LETTER FROM THE EDITOR.

Providence, (at 'the Cottage,') November 20, 1842. }

French, John R.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_R._French
: I am at the more than hospitable little retreat, a mile and a quarter out of the Roger Williams City
*Euphemism for Providence, Rhode Island, where dwell Thomas DavisDavis, Thomas

Thomas Davis (1806-95), a jeweler, immigrated to the United States from Ireland in 1817. He represented Providence in the Rhode Island senate as a Democrat from 1845 until 1853, and served on the executive committee of the Rhode Island State Anti-Slavery Society in 1849. In November 1852 Davis was elected to the U.S. House of Representatives, where he served one term. Following a failed attempt at reelection in 1855, he returned to his jewelry business in Providence. After losing three additional bids for a congressional seat, Davis returned to state politics, where he had more success. He served in the Rhode Island senate again in 1877 and 1878, and in the state house of representatives from 1887 until 1890. His wife, Paulina Kellogg Wright Davis, whom he married in 1849, was also a well-known abolitionist and women's-rights activist. NS, 30 November 1849; Washington (D.C.) National Era, 7 April 1853; Benjamin F. Moore, Providence Almanac and Business Directory for the Year 1843 (Providence, 1843 ), 46; BDUSC (online).
, and other friends of Humanity,in quarters too narrow for any but the most loving folks to inhabit in such numbers. I sit down to hurry you off some account of the recent Anti-Slavery Meetings which I left home to attend. They have been of the character distinguishing the anti-slavery movement at the present time, very informal and very interesting and profitable. They were held at the freest and kindest public edifice in Providence—the old Town HallTown House, Providence, Rhode Island

—an ancient building, in the high parts of the city. There are some historical associations about it, I do not know what particularly, a kind of Faneuil Hall. The architecture is unseemly, and it looks the worse for standing directly opposite the Atheneum, a peerless little building, of granite, that would have passed muster among architectural gems, on Old Athens, in the days of her temples and pillars. It is as beautiful as a poem, looking out from the side-hill, with two graceful weeping willows close before it. But the Old Hall has antiquity on its side, such antiquity as we have got in this unfledged country. Whether King PhilipMetacom (King Philip)

ever held his Parliament in it, or not, I don't know—or the NarragansettsNarragansett People

their Great Talks and Councils.—Anti-slavery had to go in there, or stay out doors—the great houses, which thicken all about the city, are to something beside vulgar humanity. The meetings lasted three entire days, and wound up the third afternoon, full. They grew more interesting and animated to the very last, as metings will, if conducted on the principles of freedom. They had a President—but a man above presiding. He did little else , by way of governing, than to remind the meeting it was self-governed, and this he had rare occasion to do. Peleg ClarkeClarke, Peleg

Peleg Clarke (1784-1875), a physician from Coventry, Rhode Island, was active in various reform movements, including temperance and abolitionism. The longtime president of the Rhode Island State Anti-Slavery Society, Clarke left the Quaker church to protest the denomination's lack of support of anti-slavery activities. His daughter, Lydia Clarke, was the president of the Coventry Anti-Slavery Society. Clarke was also nationally known as a leader of the Associationist movement, which located socialist "Phalanxes" or communities in New York, Pennsyhania, and areas of the Midwest. Most were tied to the philosophies of the French socialist Charles Fourier. Clarke served as a vice president of the New England Fourier Society in the 1840s and represented Rhode Island at the first convention of the American Union of Associationists in 1844. Clarke was also among the individuals responsible for the creation of the Providence Affiliated Union in 1847. The Rhode Island Fourierists had close ties with the abolitionist community, and many members were also active in antislavery reform. Although the group managed to open a Fourierist-inspired retail cooperative, no Phalanxes were established in Rhode Island. Clarke practiced homeopathic medicine in the state for over sixty years and championed temperance as well as abolitionism. William Harvey King, History of Homeopathy and Its Institutions in America, 4 vols. (New York, 1905), 1:181; Van Broekhoven, Devotion of These Women, 65-67, 69, 97, 101-02; Charles R. Crowe, "Utopian Socialism in Rhode Island," Rhode Island History, 18:20-26 (January 1959).
was the President—the author of the letter accompanying Pillsbury's phrenological characterPillsbury, Parker

The outspoken abolitionist orator, editor, and author Parker Pillsbury (1809-98) was born in Massachusetts but moved to Henniker, New Hampshire, where he farmed and worked as a wagoner until 1835. The local Congregational church there encouraged him to pursue the ministry. Pillsbury graduated from New Hampshire's Gilmanton Theological Seminary in 1838 and studied an additional year at Andover before accepting a church in Loudon, New Hampshire. Converted to abolitionism in Andover, Pillsbury incurred the displeasure of his congregation with sharp attacks on the churches' complicity with slavery. After his license to preach was revoked in 1840, he became lecturing agent for the New Hampshire, Massachusetts, and American antislavery societies, posts he held for over two decades. He edited the Concord (N.H.) Herald of Freedom in 1840 and again in 1845 and 1846 and the National Anti-Slavery Standard in 1866. He lectured widely, often in the company of Stephen S. Foster, and earned a reputation for his successful use of nonresistance in dealing with hostile crowds. Although he served on the executive committee of the New Hampshire Non-Resistance Society, he was among the strongest defenders of John Brown after the Harpers Ferry raid. During the Civil War, Pillsbury criticized Union war aims, especially before the Emancipation Proclamation, and in 1865 broke with Garrison over the necessity for continued activity by the American Anti-Slavery Society. Pillsbury helped to draft the constitution of the feminist American Equal Rights Association in 1865, served as vice president of the New Hampshire Woman Suffrage Association, and in 1868 and 1869 edited a weekly, Revolution, with Elizabeth Cady Stanton. Pillsbury completed his abolition memoirs, Acts of the Anti-Slavery Apostles, in 1883. Stacey M. Robertson, Parker Pillsbury: Radical Abolitionist, Male Feminist (Ithaca, N.Y., 2000); James M. McPherson, The Struggle for Equality: Abolitionists and the Negro in the Civil War and Reconstruction (Princeton, N.J., 1964), 59-60, 100-102, 305-07; Mabee, Black Freedom, 112, 221-23, 329; Filler, "Parker Pillsbury," 315-37; DAB, 14:608-09.
, the other day, in the Herald. They had a Business Committee—but it left the meeting quite free to do its own business. I trust, however, our friends here will soon learn to dispense altogether with these relics of legislative barbarism—even in name. A President, in my view, is a great blemish on the face of an Anti-slavery meeting. It looks upon its otherwise fair surface—something like a steeple a comely city,—or a Plantation on the face of the cultivated earth.

The day meetings were devoted to discussion, and mainly on the unfriendliness of the Clerical Order to the progress of our Moral Revolution. Wendell PhillipsPhillips, Wendell

Boston-born and Harvard-educated Wendell Phillips (1811-84) ranked second only to Garrison in influence in the American Anti-Slavery Society in the 1840s and 1850s. Bored with the legal profession and influenced by his antislavery fiancee, Ann Terry Greene, Phillips dedicated himself to abolitionism beginning in 1837. A highly gifted orator, Phillips was in demand as a lecturer even in nonabolitionist circles. Besides abolition, Phillips championed woman suffrage, prohibition, penal reform, Indian rights, and legislative protection for workers. When Garrison retired from the presidency of the American Anti-Slavery Society in 1865, Phillips assumed the post and led abolitionists until passage of the Fifteenth Amendment in 1870. James Brewer Stewart, Wendell Phillips: Liberty's Hero (Baton Rouge, La., 1986); Irving H. Bartlett, Wendell Phillips: Brahmin Radical (Boston, 1961); DAB, 14:546-47.
opposed the views of the speakers, who advocated the necessity of the demolition of this Order. He denied the great Influence attributed to the Clergy. He said they had not the abolition of Slavery in their power—that they were the mere creatures of a pro-slavery community, the mere weathercocks, showing the way of the wind, and not the authors or regulators of the storms, as speakers seemed to suppose them. He also appeared to deprecate their overthrow—even if it were practicable, which I think he denied.— It was said on the other side, that though they were put up in their elevations by the people, in the individual instances, they were obliged by the Brotherhood of Clergy, to have some one or other of their sacred number placed over them, and like the gods made with hands, they were worshipped, by the people who set them up. That with the Day at their control; too holy for free thought—in the House, at their control, too solemn for the exercise of faculties—and they themselves an infallible Order, the people could not be reached by the Abolitionists, without their consent, which consent it happened they were too pro-slavery to give. It was argued by friend Phillips that the faults of the Church and Clergy should be rebuked, and not their order and organization assailed. It was contended on the other hand, that while these were held as sacred, it was not permitted the world or the laymen to rebuke them, and that they laughed at all reproof, that left them in possession of their Infallibility.

Sundry Clergy were present. None took part in the discussion, but Martin CheeneyCheney, Martin

Born in Dover, Massachusetts, Free Will Baptist minister Martin Cheney (c. 1792-1852) first ran a grocery in Brooklyn, New York, and then presided over a congregation in Olneyville, Rhode Island, for nearly a quarter-century before his death. Cheney was a leading temperance as well as abolition advocate. At the time of his death, Douglass eulogized him as "one of the most unflinching and constant advocates of emancipation in the State of Rhode Island." Lib., 9 January 1852; FDP, 22 January 1852; Charles Henry Pope, The Cheney Genealogy (Boston, 1897), 274,322-23.
, of Olneyville, a Freewill Baptist preacher, who has borne so prominent a part always in Rhode Island abolitionism. His defection within the year, was confidently predicted at the last

annual meeting, by some of our New Hampshire “fanatics” present. The prediction proved false. Friend CheeverCheever, Friend

adhered to the Society through the year, and left it before the commencement of another. He took some part in the first day’s debates—though but little. Just before the close of the afternoon meeting, and after it seemed too late for any reply, the Reverend Tappan H. BatchelderBatchelder, Tappan H.

, of Pawtucket—a Freewill Baptist—rose—to throw in a clerical decree or two. With the whine of the denomination, and the solemn cant of the Order, he denounced the advocates of the anti-clergy doctrine, as the greatest obstacle in the way of the anti-slavery movement. He did not deign to say wherein. He only asserted the position—and with authority. The mischief done, he intimated, was in keeping good men away from the movement, by denouncing them. He added some compliments to friend Phillips, for which that eloquent brother was not probably very grateful. He had earned them not by vindicating the incumbents of the pulpit—but the pulpit itself. He had treated the Reverend Incumbents, with much more severity than his opponents, but they did not care for that. They were willing to be regarded as pro-slavery, and as the mere weather-cocks of public sentiment, provided they could only be allowed to maintain their place upon the steeple.

I knew the Reverend speaker was a divine, from his sacred tone and look, as well as from his cowardly and Jesuitical attack made when it was too late to be replied to. I was anxious the audience should know who he was and what. Pillsbury called for the announcement of his name—and before it was given, I ventured to warrant audibly that he was a Divine—which was reckoned a great indignity. It had the effect though, I think, of illustrating the Order, and of developing the estimation in which it is generally holden. The wholesale and violent denunciation of portion of the speakers, without offering a single word of reason, by the Reverend Divine, was reckoned no offence at all. But when I presumed to say I would warrant he was a clergyman, it was considered a rudeness and a sneer.

In the evening, addresses were made by RedmondRemond, Charles Lenox

Charles Lenox Remond (1810-73), the first black lecturer hired by any antislavery society, was born in Salem, Massachusetts, to the daughter of a black hero of the American Revolution and a former slave from Curaçao. In his youth, he learned about the horrors of slavery from his father and experienced the segregation and discrimination practiced by Northern whites. In the late 1820s and early 1830s, Remond read David Walker’s Appeal and became acquainted with William Lloyd Garrison, which led him to dedicate his life to abolitionism. Remond became active in reform movements at an early age. A member of the Colored Association of Massachusetts when it merged with the New England Anti-Slavery Society in 1833, he became an officer in the latter organization. He became an agent for the Liberator and joined the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society shortly thereafter. In 1838 he began lecturing for the American Anti-Slavery Society. Both his color and his ability made him a very popular speaker in both the United States and Great Britain, where he attended the World’s Anti-Slavery Convention as a delegate in 1840 in London. Remond was the sole black lecturer for antislavery societies until Frederick Douglass began speaking in 1842. For a time, Remond and Douglass worked the lecture circuit together. Douglass admired Remond, the more experienced speaker, and named a son for him. Remond traveled and lectured in the British Isles for some sixteen months. Upon his return, Remond was employed as a lecture agent by the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society. Through the 1840s, however, Remond remained a steadfast Garrisonian while Douglass began to favor political action to end slavery, and their friendship suffered. Their close association was troubled as a rift between Douglass and Garrison threatened, and in 1852 Remond announced his intention to cancel his subscription to Frederick Douglass' Paper in protest against Douglass's adoption of non-Garrisonian views of the U.S. Constitution. Their goals, however, remained the same, and like Douglass, Remond recruited black soldiers for the Massachusetts Fifty-fourth Infantry Regiment during the Civil War. After the war, just before his death, Remond urged abolitionists to continue their fight by combatting the racial prejudice that persisted in both the North and South after the end of slavery. Illness curtailed his reform activities after the war. Les Wallace, "Charles Lenox Remond: The Lost Prince of Abolitionism," NHB, 40:696-701 (May-June 1977); William E. Ward, "Charles Lenox Remond: Black Abolitionist, 1838-1873" (Ph.D. diss., Clark University, 1977); FDP, 20 May 1852; New York Daily Times, 26 December 1873; NNE, 8 January 1874; Pease and Pease, They Who Would Be Free, 46; NCAB, 2:303; DAB, 15:499-500.
and Phillips, according to announcement, which consequently were both quite dull for those speakers. speakers seldom answer expectation—especially Anti-slavery speakers, who ought to speak unpremeditatingly, and out of the abundance of the heart. – There was a full audition.

Next morning the discussions were resumed and more part taken in them by clerical brethren—not in the way of argument—but of statement of the profane and daring opinions of the abolitionists—it being considered impious heresy to question the divinity of the Clerical Order, and a sufficient condemnation of an abolitionist, to make out that he is guilty of it. They groan it out, and it goes for a knock-me-down argument, but the people are getting so bold as to begin to ask them for a . When they are obliged to give a reason, their “occupation is gone.”

The evening was occupied by three very spirited and powerful addresses, from James MunroeMunroe, James

, of Connecticut—a young man, scarce one-and-twenty—an agent of the American Society, from Phillips and from Redmond. Munroe is destined, I predict, to be one of the most able and talented speakers we have in the field. He is very promising.—Has argument—description and wit.—Tells an anecdote wonderfully well, and knows when to tell it—and is on the whole a very interesting and satisfactory speaker. He was followed by Phillips in one of his grandest moods. I am unable here to sketch his speech—but he was fully aroused, and it was a real anti-slavery delight, and stern enjoyment to listen to him. He depicted the insolent requirements of Slavery upon the North, and the vassal spirit of Northern compliance—all growing out of the of the System.

Redmond closed for the evening, with one of his luckiest outbursts.—The full house often responded with enthusiastic applause to all the speakers.

Nearly a day was spent discussing the right of unrestricted speech—and its violation in the case of the Imprisonment of BeachBeach, Thomas Parnell

. I wish this debate in particular might have been reported. The positions taken, ought to be thrown before the people as early and as widely as possible. The Right of Speech is the right Arm of our Movement, and it must be unshackled from the fetters community have bound about it,—or our anti-slavery triumph will come late, if it comes at all.

BoyleBoyle, James

James Boyle was born a Roman Catholic in Upper Ontario, but by the early 1820s, he became a Methodist minister noted for his fiery preaching. Throughout the 1820s he served at various churches, including posts in Ohio, Michigan, and upstate New York, where he became acquainted with Charles Grandison Finney. In 1831 the young John Humphrey Noyes heard Boyle in Brattleboro, Vermont. Greatly moved by Boyle’s conviction and oratory, Noyes recommended Boyle for the pastorate of the Free Church in New Haven, Connecticut. Boyle took this position in spring 1833, and he and Noyes became close. Together they developed some of the earliest tenets of perfectionism. In spring 1834 they launched a biweekly periodical, the Perfectionist, to highlight this new religions teaching. Soon, however, they parted ways as Boyle found himself increasingly unable to embrace Noyes’s more radical positions such as the possibility of actual human perfectibility through the removal of any trace of sin. By early 1835 Boyle had complete control of the Perfectionst and proceeded to contest Noyes’s teachings while espousing the free-love creed of Theophilus Gates. In 1836 Boyle left New Haven and moved to Newark, New Jersey, to live closer to Gates. In 1837 he allied himself with William Lloyd Garrison and immediate abolitionism. Boyle then relocated to Ohio, where he served as an antislavery agent and lecturer for the Ohio Anti-Slavery Society and wrote occasional articles for the Liberator. In the 1840s, he became interested in socialism and joined a Fonrierist community in Northampton, Massachusetts. At the same time, he embraced the New Covenant movement, which eschewed all formal religions organization and ritual. Boyle later followed Swedenborgianism and experimented with faith-healing. Lib., 2 August 1839, 31 March 1843; Whitney R. Cross, The Burned-Over District: The Social and Intellectual History of Enthusiastic Religion in Western New York, 1800–1850 (New York, 1950), 189–91; Robert David Thomas, The Man Who Would Be Perfect: John Humphrey Noyes and the Utopian Impulse (Philadelphia, 1977), 43–44, 70–71, 76–77; George Wallingford Noyes, Religious Experience of John Humphrey Noyes, Founder of the Oneida Community (New York, 1923), 59, 165–69, 178–85, 202–07, 253, 255, 298–301.
was present at the meetings and spoke with great power. FosterFoster, Stephen Symonds

Born in Canterbury, New Hampshire, radical abolitionist Stephen Symonds Foster (1809-81) studied at Dartmouth College. In 1837, a year before his graduation, he helped to organize the New Hampshire Young Men's Anti-Slavery Society. Foster briefly attended Union Theological Seminary in New York, but by 1839 he had repudiated the ministry. He developed his criticisms of American churches most fully in The Brotherhood of Thieves; or, A True Picture of the American Church Clergy (1843). His practice of interrupting a church service to speak out against complicity with slavery frequently provoked violent reaction. While Foster and his wife, Abby Kelley, whom he married in 1815, were agents for the American Anti-Slavery Society for nearly twenty years, their relationship with the Garrisonians was at best one of strained cooperation. Although Foster believed that the Constitution was a proslavery document, he periodically dabbled in politics. In 1843-44 he endorsed the Liberty party. In the late 1850s, having altered his view of the nature of the Constitution, Foster sought to establish a disunion party "whose avowed aim. . .[would] be the overthrow of the government. . .& whose will. . .[would] be expressed through the ballot box." In the mid-1850s he also argued in favor of slave rebellion in his Revolution the Only Remedy for Slavery (1855). A proponent of distributing land to the freedmen, Foster was disappointed with federal Reconstruction policies. He devoted the last years of his life to agitating on behalf of temperance and women's rights. Parker Pillsbury, Acts of the Anti-Slavery Apostles (Concord, N.H., 1883), 123-55; Lillie B. Chace Wyman, "Reminiscences of Two Abolitionists," New England Magazine, 27:536-50 (January 1903); Parker Pillsbury, "Stephen Symonds Foster,'' Granite Monthly, 5:369-75 (August 1882); Jane H. Pease and William H. Pease, Bound with Them in Chains: A Biographical History of the Antislavery Movement (Westport, Conn., 1972), 191-217; Louis Filler, "Parker Pillsbury: An Anti-Slavery Apostle," NEQ, 19:315-37 (September 1946); ACAB, 2:514-15; NCAB, 2:328-29; DAB, 6:558-59.
is not here, but said little or nothing till late in the meetings. Pillsbury scarcely spoke. Douglass was present, and spoke once, but under painful affliction of the lungs and at hazard of renewing a bleeding which he has lately suffered. No woman made any speech. Abel TannerTanner, Abel

spoke once with very great good sense and soundness. But it is useless to say who spoke, unless I can give what they said, which I am not able here to do. Nothing was said at the meetings of the political squabble in Rhode Island—which I was very glad of.

The Anti-Slavery Fair was held during the meetings in a neighboring Hall, where ample entertainment was provided for the friends. – Among the women most devotedly engaged in this department of the movement—at the meetings and at all times, as an abolitionist, I would speak of Lucinda WilmarthWilmarth, Lucinda

Born in Attleboro, Massachusetts, Lucinda Wilmarth (1816-44) lived in several towns in Massachusetts and Rhode Island, such as Pawtucket, Norton, and Taunton, where she taught school. She also became an organizer at abolitionist fairs and a subscription agent for antislavery newspapers. Wilmarth assumed responsibility for running the Rhode Island state antislavery office in 1842. In this post, she continued her antislavery work, managed abolitionist finances and speakers, and sheltered fugitive slaves. In 1843 Wilmarth struggled to keep the Rhode Island organization together when the last of the clergy supporters walked out of the state antislavery convention in protest at the condemnation of churches that refused to open their doors to abolitionist lecturers. Her health failed later that year, and forced her sudden resignation from her post. Lib., 31 May 1844; Van Broekhoven, Devotion of These Women, 51, 106, 190-91.
, if I had time and space to, and could say what I wanted to of her and the other women in this portion of the field. I must stop, for I am getting wearied, as well as stupid. I think Anti-slavery is alive and well in Rhode Island. Her State Society is delivered, I believe, of the last clergyman—a most felicitous occurrence, and indicating a healthy onwardness of movement.

Yours affectionately,

N. P. R.Rogers, Nathaniel Peabody

New Hampshire abolitionist Nathaniel Peabody Rogers (1794-1846) left a law practice in Plymouth to edit the Concord abolitionist weekly Herald of Freedom in 1838. He also worked to desegregate transportation facilities, promote temperance, and end capital punishment. In the mid-1840s Rogers quarreled bitterly with other Garrisonian abolitionists, charging that disunionism carried an implicit threat of war. Perry, Radical Abolitionism, 162-63; Mabee, Black Freedom, 116, 123; Robert Adams, "Nathaniel Peabody Rogers: 1794-1846," NEQ, 20:365-76 (September 1947); NCAB, 2:320.

Date
1842-11-16
Description
An ailing Douglass spoke well at the Rhode Island annual meeting.
Publisher
This document was calendared in the published volume and has not been published in full before.
Repository Collection
Herald of Freedom, November 25, 1842 (p. 2, c. 6-p. 3, c. 1)
Type
Speeches
Publication Status
Unpublished