Speeches at American Anti-Slavery Society of Western New York (Western New York Anti-Slavery Society), August 3-5, 1843

Following the disagreement between Douglass and Collins in Syracuse, Douglass met up with Jacob Ferris and Bradburn in RochesterRochester, New York

, New York to speak at the American Anti-Slavery Society of Western New York (i.e. Western New York Anti-Slavery Society) three day convention from August 3-5. However, they were persuaded to stay a fourth day as well, though it is not known if Douglass was there on the last day. Douglass played a central role, advocating for the "pure Garrisonian resolution" that "the press and the living speaker" were the "only means by which to advance the cause of abolition." Douglass also noted later the amount of Rochester-area abolitionists that had pledged support of the Liberty Party, but still allowed the Garrisonian speakers access to churches and their own homes while they visited Rochester. Douglass seems to have enjoyed his stay with the Quakers Amy and Isaac Post, who hosted him in their home once again. Douglass entertained a congregation with an abolition song before he delivered his speech on the 5th. The final day of the convention moved to the Public Square and was full of “Sabbath-breakers.” See Lampe, , (2012), 179; Blight, , (2018), 130; , August 25, 1843 (p. 1, c. 3);

, September 1, 1843 (p. 3, c. 2-3). Douglass's participation is highlighted in boldface type below.

THE CONVENTIONS

Letter from Sydney Howard Gay

JEFFERSON, Ashtabula Co. Ohio,
August 13th, 1843

DEAR FRIEND— You are aware, I suppose, that I am passing a few weeks with my friends, the agents, who are attending upon one of the series of 'The Hundred Conventions,' with a hope that some little service might be rendered the cause, and some relief given to those who intend devoting themselves for the six months to come to this work.

You will see by the date of this letter that we have passed through New-York, and are now in Ohio, where we have held two meetings, of a day each—one at this place, (Jefferson,) and the other at Ashtabula. But the account will be given of them in due course. Let me first finish with the New-York Conventions, beginning where friend White left them in his last letter.

The next appointment, succeeding the one at Seneca Falls, was at Batavia, which, for several reasons, was omitted. We reached Rochester, therefore, on Saturday, the 5th, and found the Convention of the other series, then in session, in the Bethel church. The whole of that evening was occupied by George Bradburn, in one of his able efforts, to which a large audience listened with undivided attention. It was the wish of the friends of Rochester that the meetings should be continued on the next day, (Sunday,) and as no other places could be had, the appointment was made for assembling in the public square. The meeting, I understand, was a grand one, and very fully attended, and by that class of the people especially, who are branded as habitual Sabbath-breakers, and immoral persons, by the religionists, and who are so, precisely because the church has failed always to meet the want in their soul.

Our Convention was commenced in Lockport on Sunday morning. We were welcomed to the place by Messrs. Robbins, Mead, and others, the first of whom is the only abolitionist in the place, who is not also a Liberty party man. We met other gentlemen of the same party, who attended our meetings constantly, and some of whom were well disposed towards us. Perhaps I should rather say that all were ready to give us the right hand of good fellowship, and bid us God speed! had they been left to act our their own anti-slavery feeling, unbiased by the home insinuations, and contemptible course of conduct pursued by others, whose position, as Liberty party men, gives them an influence over the honest men of that party in Western New-York; an influence as much abused as it is wholly undeserved.

You are aware, of course, that articles have appeared in the Liberty Press and Emancipator, warning third party men in New-York to beware of the 'Hundred Conventions.' These articles, especially that in the Emancipator, were filled with downright unblushing falsehood, and Joshua Leavitt, or his . cannot but have been aware, when the article in question was being written, that he was then and there, with malice prepense, writing more than one positive lie, and this, too, from the basest motives that the human heart could conceive. He was endeavoring, in fact, to put off the day of emancipation, to debar the people from hearing on the subject of slavery, to blind their eyes and close their ears, to the claims of our holy cause, for which he professes so much love, lest somebody should come to the conclusion that third party is not the best instrumentality that can be used for the slave's redemption! Or else, what is still worse, he is so ignorant and so careless of the effect of his action, that he will say what he knows to be false, regardless alike of the slave's cause, and character of those of whom, on certain points, he can know nothing, only because he bears an old grudge against somebody. Out upon such anti-slavery. The veriest pro-slavery priest in all Southland is worthy of admiration in comparison.

At Seneca Falls, third party men kept away from our meetings, warned, no doubt, by the cry of their overseer. But at Lockport, we found a feeling of hostility at first, in array against us. We went there in good faith disposed to meet Liberty party men as , and somewhat prepossessed in favor of Lockport, by the character given us or it by Abby Kelley. We knew, moreover, that third party in N. York, was frequently a very different thing from that pitiful abortion of a 'mother of harlots'—a corrupt pro-slavery church,—known as third party in Massachusetts. We supposed, therefore, that if we should be at issue at all with Lockport anti-slavery, it would be simply as to the of a third party, presuming that we were already at in all great essentials, and that they understood us, as we thought we understood them. But Leavitt's paper arrived the same morning we did, and having the confidence, as a Liberty party organ, of the Lockport men, (many of whom, we doubt not, are ignorant of the original causes of division in Massachusetts,) it fully answered the purpose of its editor. It was distinctly avowed in the course of debate, that the articles referred to had kept away many persons. Worthy followers of worthy leaders! they refused to learn from us the character of our anti-slavery, but took it upon trust from others;

'Fit body to fit head.'

It was not so with all, however. Some came ready to do us battle; some came, perhaps the most, in good faith to judge of us for what we , and not that we were .

Early in the meeting, the question of a remedy for the evils of slavery arose. 'We acknowledge,' it was said, 'all you assert, but what shall we do about it.' It was asserted (in an audience of thirty people, but the bye,) that the anti-slavery sentiment was strong among the people of Lockport, and only wanted some definite direction to show itself in action. To all this, the answer was obvious, and was given accordingly. All this was sort of bye-play, which showed itself in the first morning; showing also a smothered feeling, created by causes before referred to, striving for utterance. In the latter part of the afternoon, the same state of things arose again, and reference was made to an assertion of Charles Remond's at some former Convention, that there were but two anti-slavery clergymen in Boston, and the assertion declared to be an attack upon third party leaders in Boston, (Leavitt, Colver, &c., &c.,) which third party men here were bound to resent. Remond, in answer, referred to Colver's course in relation to the Faneuil Hall Latimer meeting. This led to a short but very animated debate, in which the Lockport men or rather a few of them, assisted by a Mr. Noble, of Albany, who happened to be present, declared that an attack had been made upon Liberty party, and that their confidence could not be shaken by any such attacks. A protest was at once made by one of us against the gentlemen assuming for themselves the position of the injured party; we declared that that position belonged to us; that we were the party attacked; that we were thrown there upon the defensive, and we should defend ourselves; we were ready, if it was desired, to open up the whole subject of old and new organization, to show the character of third party in Massachusetts, or to discuss the expediency of Liberty party in New-York. Perhaps the gentlemen who assumed to themselves the character of injured innocents, were convinced that they were wrong; perhaps the subjects on which we declared ourselves ready to meet them; were not such as they cared to discuss; perhaps they feared that Massachusetts new organization was hardly the immaculate and heaven-born cause that the Emancipator would persuade them it was; or perhaps, which I really believe to be the fact, with most of them, they felt that there might be some mistake in the matter, and that we were not quite a set as had been represented. At all events, the matter for the moment rested, and we adjourned to the evening, when a full audience gathered together to listen to Monroe.

The next morning a resolution was introduced touching the church. It in effect declared the connection between the southern church and the northern that the latter was a participant in the guilt of the former, and that neither was, therefore, the true church. The resolution stated this, which abolitionists have for years acknowledged to be a self-evident truth, in the mildest and most inoffensive language. It was discussed quietly, and without any excitement, by ourselves, and Mr. Pichard, well known to some of our Eastern friends for his labors in Lowell and elsewhere, the part winter, and who brought a strong hand and willing heart to the work. On the opposite side, a Mr. Bridgman, a Presbyterian clergyman, arrayed himself in defence of the church. He claimed to be an abolitionist, and has, we learned, suffered some persecution for his anti-slavery, for which he has my most sincere commiseration; for never, judging from the display that day, did a man deserve less to be persecuted for such a cause. That he should render himself liable to dislike, from those opposed to him, is not surprising; for I think I never witnessed a better specimen of clerical , and bitter, unmanly treatment of opponents than was presented in this person. He seemed to think himself entirely exempt form all the customs, and even decencies of debate, by which other men are governed. We think, however, the sympathies of the people were for the truth, at last, and that new organization embodied in the Mr. Bridgman, and attempted to be smuggled in through Emancipators and Liberty Presses, has not really stood in the way of the progress of the cause at this time, but has been rather defeated in its machinations. Remond lectured in the town in the evening, according to previous arrangement, though the appointment had been nearly frustrated by two prominent church members, who stole the key of the meeting-house, to prevent a meeting. Somebody however got into the window, and opened the doors from the inside, and the people poured in in all the greater numbers, to learn what it was that church members would keep from them by an mean a trick. Lockport has got something to reflect upon for a little while, and the Liberty party men will, I hope, look into this matter of new-organization and third party conjoined in Massachusetts, and probe its rottenness. Much of the material of that party in Lockport, and elsewhere in New-York, is too good and too true to be under the guidance and control of those who have once betrayed the cause of the slave and who, no doubt, are as ready to do it again.

So ended the New-York Conventions. Having been there but a few days, I am not qualified to speak with confidence of the character of the anti-slavery of the State. But this I may say, that, notwithstanding the difficult from various quarters which the agents have had to encounter, great good has been done, and that fruits of these Conventions will be seen for a long time to come.

I have already written a longer letter than I ought, but I wished to be particular in regard to this Lockport meeting, not only because I thought it would be interesting to you, and other friends in Boston, but as a lesson, which to younger abolitionists, who think the matter of old and new organization all nonsense, might be of service. We passed a day and a half at Niagara, and were indeed refreshed in body and in spirit. It was true rest to see and hear the rushing of its mighty waters. If we did not learn there any new lessons, we conned over in newer and stronger lights, some old ones, which will not unfit us to work in the cause of God and humanity.

We are now at the house of the Hon. J. R. Giddings. The reception we have met with—the meetings we have held here—the character of the anti-slavery in Ohio, at first sight—and many other things which I long to write about, under this date, must be deferred till another time. This letter is already too long.

Truly your friend,

SYDNEY HOWARD GAY.

Letter from Charles Lenox Remond.
Western New York,
Buffalo, Aug. 12, 1843.

ESTEEMED FRIEND:

Presuming that my good friends and fellow-laborers, Messrs. White, Monroe, and Gay have kept you informed of our principal movements, I take my pen more for the purpose of making good my promise than otherwise. Our appointments, you will perceive, have been tolerably punctually kept in this State, and with the exception of Albany, have all been much better attended and more interest awakened, than I anticipated, considereing the means and measures used to prevent the people from coming out. I find many, apparently unhappy, and others affect to be shocked at the remarks reported to my account, on the Liberty party in New Bedford, not long sice, by our worthy friend, E. Quincy, in the Liberator. The Albany Patriot and Liberty Press have opened their columns to anonymous communications, exercising the largest liberty of the press on me, upon presumption the report is a correct one, since I have in no instance disclaimed it. Now I confess I am amused at the sensitivities of the gentlemen on this subject, and who manifest large courage in their false statements, and more contemptible comments, but not enough courage to write over their true signatures, otherwise I should have noticed their 'Liberty party' highnesses at an earlier day. Though I did not use, without limitation, the language attributed to me by Mr. Quincy, yet as I don't know that I differ from the view very materially, I am willing the anonymous writers should make the most of the report, so far as the fate of Massachusetts is concerned; and I must go further by adding that I differ some from our friends, in their idea that Liberty party in New-York differs so very widely from that of the same name of our State. For instance, I heard much of Lockport: in fact, my expectations ran high before my arrival, on the highminded, liberal, free and thoroughgoing abolitionism of the Liberty party advocates of this village, and here, of all places, I expected we should be welcomed and presumed to be disinterested in our position, until proved guilty of holding and advancing doctrines irreconcilable with genuine anti-slavery, they being judges. But I was disappointed [For particulars, see letter of Mr. Gay.]

Sydney H. Gay presented a very reasonable and simple resolution on the Church connexion with slavery, when a warm and somewhat protracted discussion ensued. Messrs. Bridgeman, Chace, Southworth and Prudence, opposing very strenuously, and Messrs. Gay, Monroe, White, Pickard and myself, advocating, and here I must do Mr. Pickard the justice by saying his course was characterized by the same frank, honorable and truly liberal spirit manifested in his sojourn and attendance on meeting in Massachusetts during the last winter, and those friends who heard him during the Conventions and discussions on the Church and clergy, will be pleased to learn that he acquitted himself in Lockport in the 'trial hour' of truth struggling against error and sectarianism, in a manner not less worthy of his power, intelligence and eloquence. I regard him among the faithful few; and the poor slave is indebted to him for his unyielding advocacy of truth and principle. And I would not omit to mention our good and true friends Mr. Robbins, who presided over the meeting, together with Messrs. Mead, Kline and Mott and family, the latter being the brother of our worthy friends, the Misses Mott, of Albany. My time will not permit me to add more than the intimation that our meetings resulted in much good, and in the advancement of free principles. The resolution alluded to, was lost by a vote of 27 to 18, being a signal victory over the expectations of our opponents.

Of the meetings being at this time holden by Douglass and myself, I will speak in my next. Frederick and myself intend remaining during the sitting of the Convention of the people of color, and shall then join our respective parties in Ohio with all possible despatch. Please excuse this hurried and rambling communication—and begging to be affectionately remembered to the several members of your family, and the friends generally,

I remain, very truly,

Your obliged friend,

C. LENOX REMONDRemond, Charles Lenox

Charles Lenox Remond (1810-73), the first black lecturer hired by any antislavery society, was born in Salem, Massachusetts, to the daughter of a black hero of the American Revolution and a former slave from Curaçao. In his youth, he learned about the horrors of slavery from his father and experienced the segregation and discrimination practiced by Northern whites. In the late 1820s and early 1830s, Remond read David Walker’s Appeal and became acquainted with William Lloyd Garrison, which led him to dedicate his life to abolitionism. Remond became active in reform movements at an early age. A member of the Colored Association of Massachusetts when it merged with the New England Anti-Slavery Society in 1833, he became an officer in the latter organization. He became an agent for the Liberator and joined the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society shortly thereafter. In 1838 he began lecturing for the American Anti-Slavery Society. Both his color and his ability made him a very popular speaker in both the United States and Great Britain, where he attended the World’s Anti-Slavery Convention as a delegate in 1840 in London. Remond was the sole black lecturer for antislavery societies until Frederick Douglass began speaking in 1842. For a time, Remond and Douglass worked the lecture circuit together. Douglass admired Remond, the more experienced speaker, and named a son for him. Remond traveled and lectured in the British Isles for some sixteen months. Upon his return, Remond was employed as a lecture agent by the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society. Through the 1840s, however, Remond remained a steadfast Garrisonian while Douglass began to favor political action to end slavery, and their friendship suffered. Their close association was troubled as a rift between Douglass and Garrison threatened, and in 1852 Remond announced his intention to cancel his subscription to Frederick Douglass' Paper in protest against Douglass's adoption of non-Garrisonian views of the U.S. Constitution. Their goals, however, remained the same, and like Douglass, Remond recruited black soldiers for the Massachusetts Fifty-fourth Infantry Regiment during the Civil War. After the war, just before his death, Remond urged abolitionists to continue their fight by combatting the racial prejudice that persisted in both the North and South after the end of slavery. Illness curtailed his reform activities after the war. Les Wallace, "Charles Lenox Remond: The Lost Prince of Abolitionism," NHB, 40:696-701 (May-June 1977); William E. Ward, "Charles Lenox Remond: Black Abolitionist, 1838-1873" (Ph.D. diss., Clark University, 1977); FDP, 20 May 1852; New York Daily Times, 26 December 1873; NNE, 8 January 1874; Pease and Pease, They Who Would Be Free, 46; NCAB, 2:303; DAB, 15:499-500.
.

Date
1843-08-03
Description
Douglass speaks at an "Hundred Conventions" event and stays with the Post family.
Publisher
This document was calendared in the published volume and has not been published in full before.
Repository Collection
Liberator, September 1, 1843 (p. 3, c. 2-3).
Type
Speeches
Publication Status
Unpublished