Attendance at a Three Day Convention in Nantucket, Massachusetts, June 23-25, 1843.

Continuing a series of lectures in and around New Bedford in June 1843, Douglass attended at least a part of a three day convention being held in Nantucket from June 23-25 in the Atheneum Hall. On the first day, Douglass was appointed to the Business Committee and spoke on the deplorable relationship between the Church and slavery. On the second day, George Bradburn spoke and argued that the Constitution was not a proslavery document. Douglass, responding in typical Garrisonian fashion, argued against Bradburn. Taking offense at being contradicted by a Black man, Bradburn left the floor rather than continue the debate. On the final day, Douglass spoke about why the Sabbath was an appropriate time to discuss slavery. See also, Lampe, , (2012), 173.

, July 14, 1843 (p. 2, c. 3-5).

From the Nantucket TelegraphNantucket Telegraph

.

Proceecings of an Anti-Slavery Convention holden in Nantucket.

The Convention assembled at the Atheneum HallAtheneum Hall, Nantucket, Mass.

, June 23d, at 9 o'clock, and was called to order by George BradburnBradburn, George

Son of a woolens manufacturer in Attleboro, Massachusetts. George Bradburn (1806-80) trained for the Unitarian ministry, but subsequently devoted his energies to championing numerous secular reforms. Bradburn also acted as an agent for the American Anti-Slavery Society in 1839, and he attended the World's Anti-Slavery Convention in 1840. He was not a strict Garrisonian however, opposing all propositions in favor of dissolving the Union and favoring political means to accomplish the abolition of slavery. Bradburn represented Nantucket as a Whig in the state legislature (1839- 42), where he led the successful effort to repeal Massachusetts's antimiscegenation law. In the 1840s he lectured for the (Garrisonians and traveled with Douglass on many occasions. He later joined the Free Soil party and edited two Free Soil newspapers, the Pioneer and Herald of Freedom and the True Democrat. In addition to abolitionism. Bradburn supported women 's rights, temperance, pacifism, and an end to capital punishment. Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society, Eleventh Annual Report: Presented to the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society by its Board of Directors (Boston, 1843 ), 44, 90-91; idem. Twelfth Annual Report: Presented to the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society (Boston. 1844), 34; George Bradburn, A Memorial of George Bradburn, comp. Frances H. Bradburn (Boston, 1883).
, who explained in behalf of the Committee of Arrangements the object and nature of the meeting.

On motion, Cyrus PiercePierce, Cyrus

was called to the chair as President of the Convention, and Isaac AustinAustin, Isaac

and Thomas MacyMacy, Thomas

were elected Vice-Presidents, and Andrew M. MacyMacy, Andrew, M.

and Anna Gardner Secretaries.

The following persons were appointed a Business Committee:—Geo. Bradburn, Charlotte Austin JoyAustin, Charlotte

, Frederick Douglass, and Elize BarneyBarney, Eliza

.

The meeting was addressed, in the course of the morning, Dr. RobinsonRobinson, Dr.

, S. S. FosterFoster, Stephen Symonds

Born in Canterbury, New Hampshire, radical abolitionist Stephen Symonds Foster (1809-81) studied at Dartmouth College. In 1837, a year before his graduation, he helped to organize the New Hampshire Young Men's Anti-Slavery Society. Foster briefly attended Union Theological Seminary in New York, but by 1839 he had repudiated the ministry. He developed his criticisms of American churches most fully in The Brotherhood of Thieves; or, A True Picture of the American Church Clergy (1843). His practice of interrupting a church service to speak out against complicity with slavery frequently provoked violent reaction. While Foster and his wife, Abby Kelley, whom he married in 1815, were agents for the American Anti-Slavery Society for nearly twenty years, their relationship with the Garrisonians was at best one of strained cooperation. Although Foster believed that the Constitution was a proslavery document, he periodically dabbled in politics. In 1843-44 he endorsed the Liberty party. In the late 1850s, having altered his view of the nature of the Constitution, Foster sought to establish a disunion party "whose avowed aim. . .[would] be the overthrow of the government. . .& whose will. . .[would] be expressed through the ballot box." In the mid-1850s he also argued in favor of slave rebellion in his Revolution the Only Remedy for Slavery (1855). A proponent of distributing land to the freedmen, Foster was disappointed with federal Reconstruction policies. He devoted the last years of his life to agitating on behalf of temperance and women's rights. Parker Pillsbury, Acts of the Anti-Slavery Apostles (Concord, N.H., 1883), 123-55; Lillie B. Chace Wyman, "Reminiscences of Two Abolitionists," New England Magazine, 27:536-50 (January 1903); Parker Pillsbury, "Stephen Symonds Foster,'' Granite Monthly, 5:369-75 (August 1882); Jane H. Pease and William H. Pease, Bound with Them in Chains: A Biographical History of the Antislavery Movement (Westport, Conn., 1972), 191-217; Louis Filler, "Parker Pillsbury: An Anti-Slavery Apostle," NEQ, 19:315-37 (September 1946); ACAB, 2:514-15; NCAB, 2:328-29; DAB, 6:558-59.
, Cyrus BurleighBurleigh, Cyrus M.

, Geo. Bradburn and Henry Clapp, Jr.Clapp, Henry, Jr.

The Business Committee reported the following resolutions:

1. Resolved, That chattel slavery is inherently a system of abuse, which cannot be ameliorated until abolished; and that the master's denial to slaves of the Bible, and of education, of the right of testimony and of jury trial, the abolition among them of the marriage institution, the separation of parents and children, and husbands and wives, and the unrestrained use of the scourge, the rifle and the bloodhound, are indispensable requisites to the support of the property principle in man.

2. Resolved, That in the words of J. G. BirneyBirney, James Gillespie

Son of a wealthy Kentucky slaveowner, James Gillespie Birney (1792-1857) moved to Alabama in 1818. There he helped shape the antislavery features of the state's new constitution and served one term in the state legislature. Birney was a leading colonizationist and advocate of gradual emancipation from the mid-1820s to 1834, when he publicly endorsed immediate emancipation and freed his six slaves. He published the antislavery newspaper the Philanthropist, first in Kentucky and then in Ohio. Birney served as executive secretary of the American Anti-Slavery Society in the late 1830s and as the Liberty party's presidential candidate in 1840 and 1844. Betty Fladeland, James Gillespie Birney: Slaveholder to Abolitionist (1955; New York, 1969); NCAB, 2:312-13; DAB, 2:291-94.
, 'The American Churches are the bulwarks of American slavery.'

3. Resolved, That southern slavery could not be sustained, but for the support it derives from the voters of the nominally free States.

Dr. Robinson moved to amend the last resolution by striking out the words free States, and substituting the words, 'the freeholders in the non-slaveholding States'—on the ground that there was no free States in the Union. In the course of his remarks, Dr. Robinson advocated the Repeal of the Union, as the only consistent course of true abolitionists.

After some discussion, Dr. Robinson withdrew his amendment, it being stated by the Chairman of the Committee that the term 'free States' was used for sake of convenience and in its technical sense, they being well convinced that there wsa not a free State in the Union.

On motion of Isaac Austin, the chair was to appoint a Financial Committee of five, to raise funds to defray the current expenses of the Convention.

After being favored by a stirring song from the Hutchinsons, the Convention adjourned to meet in the afternoon at 2 o'clock in the same place.

AFTERNOON SESSION.

The President in the chair. Both Secretaries being absent, H. Clapp, Jr. was appointed Secretary pro tem.

The 2d resolution of the Business Committee, Resolved, that in the words of J. G. Birney, the American Church is the bulwark of American slavery, was then taken up and discussed by Elias SmithSmith, Elias

This is probably Elias Smith (1815–17), a Methodist minister and antislavery advocate in New York City. He was noted for being a friend of Garrison. Dale Cockrell, ed., Excelsior: Journals of the Hutchinson Family Singers, 1842–1846, (New York, 1989), 192n27.
, Frederick Douglass, John AllenAllen, John

, S. S. Foster, Cyrus Burleigh, H. Clapp, Jr. and Rev. Mr. Smith, all in the affirmative.

On motion of George Bradburn, Voted that the resolutions be taken from the table to be discussed separately or collectively, as the different speakers may see fit.

On motion of S. S. Foster, the following preamble and resolution was offered for discussion:

5. Whereas, the Constitution of the United States requires the citizens of the several States to deliver up fugitives from slavery on claim of their masters, and to put down the slaves should they attempt to regain their liberty by a resort to arms; and whereas, the three political parties into which the community is now divided, are publicly pledged to execute all the provisions of that slaveholding instrument without exception or abatement; therefore,

Resolved, That no person can act in concert with either of these parties, without giving his countenance and support to the infernal slave system, and thereby incurring the guilt of slaveholding.

Wm. P. Powell, of New-York, offered the following resolution, which was accepted:

Whereas, we learn with pain that Thomas Israel, a citizen of New Bedford, on or about the 2d of May last past, left the port of Boston in the due prosecution of his lawful business of a mariner, was seized upon at the port of New-Orleans, and without any color of crime, was imprisoned, contrary to the 2d sec. of the 4th article of the Constitution of the United States; therefore,

Resolved, That the imprisonment of said citizen at the port of New-Orleans, is an insult to the State of Massachusetts, and an outrage upon the Constitution not to be endured under any circumstances whatever.

That a representation of facts be made to Gov. Morton, and he be requested to take the necessary steps to maintain and enforce the laws of this State protecting her citizens from imprisonment in the slaveholding States on account of their color.

The chair appointed the following gentlemen as the Financial Committee: David Joy, Francis B. Folger, Alaxander H. Robinson, G. W. Wright, and J. Macy.

The Hutchinsons sang one of their beautiful songs.

The meetings during both sessions were replete with interest. In the morning, the main idea was, that we could only wash our hands of the sin of slavery, by refusing all political or other participation in it. It did not appear evident to the speakers, how a man could swear to support a slave-making Constitution, without swearing to support slavery; nor how a man could advocate an union with slaveholding States, without advocating an union with slavery.

In the afternoon, the leading idea appeared to be, that the the Church was the corner-stone of slavery, not that was pro-slavery, but that the Christianity of the Church and the clergy was pro-slavery in its very essence.

The priesthood were represented as a band of time-serving hirelings—and the Church as being filled with the spirit of Satan.

MORNING SESSION.

The President called the meeting to order, and opened it with reading a portion of Scripture.

On motion of S. S. Foster, a Committee was appointed to wait upon the clergy of this town, and invite them to attend this Convention, and participate in its proceedings so far as they may feel interested. The following persons were nominated by the chair:

Eliza Barney, E. W. Gardner, Phebe W. Gardner, Thomas Rand, Harriet Pierce, and Job Coleman.

Job Coleman desired that he should be authorized to say to the clergy that they should be treated with respect;—but there was a general expression of dislike to such a pledge. It was considered gratuitous to that the clergy would be treated with other than respect by the Convention They would receive all the respect to which they are entitled.

On motion of S. S. Foster, resolution No. 3 was so far amended as to substitute 'nominally free States,' for 'free States;' on the ground that there are no free States excepting by profession.

Mr. S. S. Foster then called up his resolution (No. 5) and discussed an amendment proposed by Cyrus Burleigh, with that gentleman.

The meeting was also addressed on this subject by James Monroe, W. P. Powell, and John A. Collins.

Mr. DeanDean, Rev.

, of New-Bedford, a come-outer from the pro-slavery clergy, gave an account of his conversion to anti-slavery, and of his change from a preacher for the devil to a preacher for Christ.

Mr. Foster called on Mr. Bradburn to support the negative of his resolution, and Mr. B. respondedd. Mr Foster then resumed his remarks.

On motion, it was voted to hold an evening session at the Town Hall, and to adjourn this meeting at 2 o'clock, P. M.

The Hutchinsons sang one of their songs, which concluded the services of the morning.

The views which characterized the discussion of the morning, and which were put forth with great power, were, that no man can be a consistent friend of the slave, and at the same time swear obedience to the Constitution of the United States. It was strennuously contended, if a man swear to obey that Constitution, and then refuse to execute its promise, he is a perjurer, and unworthy of the confidence even of the slaveholder; and that, therefore, as that Constitution provides for the giving up of refugee slaves, no abolitionist can subscribe to it;—for, if he assisted in such an infernal business, he would be worse than the slaveholder himself—and if he did not assist, having agreed to by his signature to the instrument, to do so, he would be a liar and a perjurer in the sight of God and man.

The view was also advanced, that as the Constitution provides for a slave rerpresentation in Congress, and as there are now thirty members of the national Legislature representing, or rather misrepresenting the slave population of the country, and crushing the poor slave by their votes,—therefore, every man who pledges himself to the support of the Constitution of the United States, does virtually pledge himself to the support of slavery.

Mr. Bradburn stood alone in opposition to these views, taking the ground that the Constitution as a whole is not pro-slavery.

To this, Mr. Foster replied, that one thing is clear, and that is, if Mr. Bradburn swore to support the Constitution, he swore to become the body-guard of the slaveholder; to defend him against the insurrections of the slave; and that, if he took such an oath, and then in case of an insurrection, refused to abide by it, the slaveholder would have a right to rebuke him, as being a faithless man, untrue to his promises, and false to his oath. In such a case, the slaveolder might say—'Had not your freemen of New-England pledged yourselves to support us in such an emergency, we might have given up our slaves;—but as you—you freemen, yes, you abolitionists—did solemnly swear to assist us in case our slaves rose against us, we felt secure; and therefore we have no respect for you. We could respect you, had you boldly refused to give in your adherence to the Constitution;—but we must you when you swear to give in that adherence, and then back out when the emergency comes.'

It is proper to add, that Mr. Bradburn had not time to respond to these views, and no one else attempted it.

AFTERNOON SESSION.

Met agreeably to adjournment. President in the chair. Discussion was continued on the resolution of Elias Smith. The Committee appointed to wait upon the clergy, reported that they had but partially attended to the duty allotted them.

S. S. Foster continued his remarks on the resolution in reply to Mr. Bradburn, showing in a clear and conclusive manner the ground maintained by Mr. B. to be untenable. Mr. Bradburn followed, and went into an elaborate argument to prove the truth of his position.

Charles L. RemondRemond, Charles Lenox

Charles Lenox Remond (1810-73), the first black lecturer hired by any antislavery society, was born in Salem, Massachusetts, to the daughter of a black hero of the American Revolution and a former slave from Curaçao. In his youth, he learned about the horrors of slavery from his father and experienced the segregation and discrimination practiced by Northern whites. In the late 1820s and early 1830s, Remond read David Walker’s Appeal and became acquainted with William Lloyd Garrison, which led him to dedicate his life to abolitionism. Remond became active in reform movements at an early age. A member of the Colored Association of Massachusetts when it merged with the New England Anti-Slavery Society in 1833, he became an officer in the latter organization. He became an agent for the Liberator and joined the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society shortly thereafter. In 1838 he began lecturing for the American Anti-Slavery Society. Both his color and his ability made him a very popular speaker in both the United States and Great Britain, where he attended the World’s Anti-Slavery Convention as a delegate in 1840 in London. Remond was the sole black lecturer for antislavery societies until Frederick Douglass began speaking in 1842. For a time, Remond and Douglass worked the lecture circuit together. Douglass admired Remond, the more experienced speaker, and named a son for him. Remond traveled and lectured in the British Isles for some sixteen months. Upon his return, Remond was employed as a lecture agent by the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society. Through the 1840s, however, Remond remained a steadfast Garrisonian while Douglass began to favor political action to end slavery, and their friendship suffered. Their close association was troubled as a rift between Douglass and Garrison threatened, and in 1852 Remond announced his intention to cancel his subscription to Frederick Douglass' Paper in protest against Douglass's adoption of non-Garrisonian views of the U.S. Constitution. Their goals, however, remained the same, and like Douglass, Remond recruited black soldiers for the Massachusetts Fifty-fourth Infantry Regiment during the Civil War. After the war, just before his death, Remond urged abolitionists to continue their fight by combatting the racial prejudice that persisted in both the North and South after the end of slavery. Illness curtailed his reform activities after the war. Les Wallace, "Charles Lenox Remond: The Lost Prince of Abolitionism," NHB, 40:696-701 (May-June 1977); William E. Ward, "Charles Lenox Remond: Black Abolitionist, 1838-1873" (Ph.D. diss., Clark University, 1977); FDP, 20 May 1852; New York Daily Times, 26 December 1873; NNE, 8 January 1874; Pease and Pease, They Who Would Be Free, 46; NCAB, 2:303; DAB, 15:499-500.
replied with some warmth to a remark fo Mr. Bradburn. 'that the emancipation of a handful of negroes at the South, when compared to the other evils which affect humanity, is of minor importance.' He maintained with great force and eloquence, that slavery is the alphabet of the whole catalogue of crimes perpetrated in our country, and that all classes are equally effected by it. Frederick Douglass deprecated the course of remark pursued by Mr. Bradburn.

Mr. Dean expressed his surprise that he (Mr. B.) shuld have so little faith in moral instrumentality to effect the abolition of slavery.

Mr. Bradburn having left the Hall, Andrew M. Macy protested against the injustice with which Mr. Remond and others had treated that gentleman. He said they had first totally perverted his remarks, and then on their unfair construction of them had based an attack on him as unjust as it was ungentlemanly. All Mr. Bradburn said was, that in comparison with which afflict humanity, southern slavery was but a sort of secondary matter. To this, every true-hearted man must say amen, even Mr. Remond himself.

After a few remarks by Rev. Mr. Smith, the meeting adjourned.

EVENING SESSION.

Met agreeably to adjournment. President in the chair.

On motion of Elias Smith, it was voted, that when we adjourn, it be to meet to-morrow morning at 9 o'clock, in the Atheneum Hall.

On motion of I. Austin, voted, that the convention meet in the Town Hall to-morrow (Sunday evening) at 7 1-2 o'clock.

Elias Smith spoke in support of the following resolutions:

Resolved, That the Convention have learned with emotions of the highest satisfaction, that the New-England Convention have projected and intended to hold a grand series of Conventions for the slaves' cause, in the great West, during the present summer and coming autumn.

Resolved, That the efficient and self-sacrificing labors, continued with little interruption for a long series of years in this State, in the anti-slavery cause, have devolved upon the abolitionists of Massachusetts, a weighty obligation to act in the true missionary spirit, and impact according to their ability to sustain the New-England Convention in carrying into effect, this truly magnificent enterprise in behalf of our enslaved countrymen.

On motion, voted to lay the resolutions on the table.

S. S. Foster spoke at some length on the guilty participancy of the church with slavery; proving conclusively that the connection is of the most intimate and enduring nature.

He was followed by J. Otis Wattles of Ohio, on the same subject.

On motion, voted to adjourn.

MORNING SESSION, June 25th.

Met according to adjournment.

In the absence of the President, the Vice-President, Isaac Austin, took the chair.

The meeting was opened by reading a portion of scripture.

Frederick Douglass commented at some length, on the reasons which he deemed made it peculiarly appropriate to devote the Sabbath day to the discussion of American slavery. The remainder of the forenoon was occupied by Rev. John Allen and Rev. Mr. Dean, whose remarks were appropriate and impressive.

On motion, voted to adjourn to meet at the Atheneum at 2 o'clock in the afternoon.

AFTERNOON SESSION.

Met agreeably to adjournment. I. Austin in the chair.

The resolution respecting the guilt of the church in giving its support to slavery, was discussed at some length by Henry Clapp, Jr. and Cyrus M. Burleigh. Mr. Burleigh read frin a sermon of J. S. C. Abbott, lately published in pamphlet form, a declaration that the New-England Congregational Association had for several years borne a faithful testimony against slavery. This he denied; and declared that no Congregational association in New-England (except in Vermont) had ever declared slavery under to be a sin. This he proved conclusively by a series incontrovertible facts. He was followed by S. S. Foster, in a powerful and impressive speech, in which he denounced in bold and unconditional terms, those professed religionists, who substitute a close adhesion to outward forms and ceremonies, for the true love of God and humanity—and endeavored to prove by facts and arguments drawn from scripture, that public prayers and church ceremonies, are in direct violation of the spirit and letter of Christ's teaching; that living a life of impartial and universal love, and serving our fellow beings is the worship most acceptable to God. Frederick Douglass, W. P. PowellPowell, William Peter

William Peter Powell (1807-c. 1879), a Garrisonian abolitionist and reformer, was born free in New York, the son of a free woman and an enslaved father. Powell apprenticed as a sailor and lived and worked in New Bedford, Massachusetts, where he helped to found a local antislavery society, became one of the first members of the New England Anti-Slavery Society, and joined the American Seaman's Friend Society. In 1839 he moved to New York City, opening the Colored Seamen's Home, an employment agency and boardinghouse for black sailors. Powell remained active in abolitionist circles and also supported women's rights, black selfhelp, and temperance reform. He served as secretary of the Garrisonian Manhattan Anti-Slavery Society and was among those who established the Committee of Thirteen, an organization of prominent African Americans opposed to the Fugitive Slave Law and other forms of racial discrimination. In early 1852 he moved to Great Britain, where he remained active in abolitionist circles, returning to the United States in 1861. Upon his return Powell reestablished the Colored Seamen's Home and in 1863 accepted a commission in the U.S. Navy. During the July 1863 New York draft riots, a white mob looted Powell's boardinghouse, causing almost $5,000 in property damage. Following the Civil War, he remained an activist seeking to improve the working conditions of African American sailors. Merrill and Ruchames, Garrison Letters, 3:72n; Ripley, Black Abolitionist Papers, 3:302-03; ANB, 17:786-87.
, and Cyrus Burleigh dissented from some of the views expressed by Mr. Foster.

Some conversation followed as to the designation of speakers, and the Convention adjourned.

EVENING SESSION.

Met according to adjournment in the Town Hall. Isaac Austin in the chair.

On motion, the first, second, third and fifth resolutions were adopted.

The evening was occupied with interesting and effective speeches from Charles L. Remond and S. S. Foster. Mr. Foster gave an account of imprisonments which he has undergone from time to time, for attempting to speak in churches without permission from authorities, together with his reasons for so doing.

After which, the Convention adjourned .

C. PEIRCE, .

HENRY CLAPP JR. ANNA GARDNER, } .

Creator
Douglass, Frederick, 1818-1895
Date
1843-06-23
Description
Douglass spoke several times at a three day convention in Nantucket.
Publisher
This document was calendared in the published volume and has not been published in full before.
Repository Collection
Liberator, July 14, 1843 (p. 2, c. 3-5).
Type
Speeches
Publication Status
Unpublished