"A Christian cannot fight with carnal weapons": Lecture in Osterville, Massachusetts, June 19, 1842.
As part of a tour of the towns along Cape Cod preaching nonresistence, Douglass, Bradburn and Garrison lectured in osterville on June 19, 1842. Both meetings that day (morning and evening), were reported as being "well attended." All three men spoke in favor of resolutions declaring that Christians ought not to fight against slavery with "carnal" weapons, asseritng that they should not take life nor support those who sought to end slavery by such means. In Garrison's estimation of the event, Douglass was the star of the show, engrossing the audience with his charm and passion. See Lampe, Frederick Douglass, (2012), 120-121.
, July 8, 1842 (p. 3, c. 1). Douglass's participation is highlighted in boldfact type below.
Trip to the Cape.
Our next meetings, on Cape Cod, were held at OstervilleOsterville, Massachusetts
, on Sunday afternoon and evening, the 19th ult. These were well attended, and devoted to a free discussion of the following resolution;
'Resolved, That a Christian cannot fight, with carnal weapons, against his enemies, or the enemies of others; nor take the life of his fellow-man, nor assist or empower others to take it, either in self-defence or as a penalty for crime.'
IGarrison, William Lloyd
William Lloyd Garrison (1805-79) was the foremost white abolitionist of the nineteenth century and was credited with the discovery of Douglass as a speaker at an antislavery meeting in Nantucket in 1841. He began his career as an apprentice printer on the Newburyport (Mass.) Herald at the age of thirteen. Garrison became editor of the Newburyport Free Press in 1826, but the paper closed within a year. He was then associated with a series of periodicals in Boston that advocated reform before Benjamin Lundy offered the young journalist the opportunity to write for his antislavery newspaper. Garrison joined Lundy in editing the Genius of Universal Emancipation in Baltimore, Maryland, in 1829, during the last year of the paper's 1821-1830 run. In 1830 a libel suit against the editors forced the paper to close and landed Garrison in jail. After his release, he courted the wealthy merchants of New York and Boston in order to start the Liberator (1831-65), a weekly journal based in Boston in which he advocated an immediate end to slavery. Garrison's brand of abolition condemned any institution that would tolerate the existence of slavery, including churches, political parties. and even the United States itself and any scheme aimed at removing black people from the country. Instead, Garrison hoped to raise the public's awareness that slavery was morally wrong and thereby force its end in an almost millennial moment of emancipation. His approach appealed to both white and black antislavery advocates but earned him many enemies among those only moderately opposed to slavery and slaveholders alike. Seeing the need for greater action and organization beyond the pages of the Liberator; Garrison joined with other abolitionists to form the New England Anti-Slavery Society in 1831. Two years later he helped found the larger American Anti-Slavery Society. In 1833 he established ties with English abolitionists after a trip to Great Britain, and he later brought the noted and notorious speaker George Thompson to the United States for a tour. Garrison also dedicated himself to women's rights, encouraging women to enter the public sphere by inviting them, via the Liberator, to form female antislavery societies. In addition to the thirty-three women's antislavery societies that flourished by 1838, Garrison's American Anti-Slavery Society welcomed women as well as blacks into its ranks. However, female delegates were excluded from the World's Anti-Slavery Convention of 1840 in London. The issue of women's participation in the antislavery movement and Garrison's absolute refusal to turn to politics to end slavery caused a division in the American Anti-Slavery Society. Brothers Lewis and Arthur Tappan, who opposed women's acting as speakers and who hoped to use politics toward abolition, broke with Garrison's American Anti-Slavery Society, forming the American and Foreign Anti-Slavery Society, or the "New Organization" in 1841. Garrison's ideas were so closely associated with the "Old Organization" that the American Anti-Slavery Society became known simply as the "Garrisonians." With the passage of the Thirteenth Amendment in 1865, Garrison believed that he had accomplished his life's work and that of the antislavery movement. He then resigned from the presidency of the American Anti-Slavery Society and closed the Liberator. Wendell Phillips Garrison and Francis Jackson Garrison, William Lloyd Garrison, 1805-1879: The Story of His Life Told by His Children, 4 vols. (New York, 188589); Henry Mayer, All on Fire: William Lloyd Garrison and the Abolition of Slavery (New York, 1998); James Brewer Stewart, William Lloyd Garrison and the Challenge of Emancipation (Arlington Heights, Ill., 1992); John L. Thomas, The Liberator: William Lloyd Garrison (Boston, 1963); Dictionary of American Biography, 20 vols. (New York, 1928-36), 7:168-72.
endeavored, in the afternoon, to support this resolution by an exhibition of the nature, design and power of Christianity, and by exposing the fallacy of various objections which are brought against the doctrine of non-resistance. My friend George BradburnBradburn, George
Son of a woolens manufacturer in Attleboro, Massachusetts. George Bradburn (1806-80) trained for the Unitarian ministry, but subsequently devoted his energies to championing numerous secular reforms. Bradburn also acted as an agent for the American Anti-Slavery Society in 1839, and he attended the World's Anti-Slavery Convention in 1840. He was not a strict Garrisonian however, opposing all propositions in favor of dissolving the Union and favoring political means to accomplish the abolition of slavery. Bradburn represented Nantucket as a Whig in the state legislature (1839- 42), where he led the successful effort to repeal Massachusetts's antimiscegenation law. In the 1840s he lectured for the (Garrisonians and traveled with Douglass on many occasions. He later joined the Free Soil party and edited two Free Soil newspapers, the Pioneer and Herald of Freedom and the True Democrat. In addition to abolitionism. Bradburn supported women 's rights, temperance, pacifism, and an end to capital punishment. Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society, Eleventh Annual Report: Presented to the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society by its Board of Directors (Boston, 1843 ), 44, 90-91; idem. Twelfth Annual Report: Presented to the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society (Boston. 1844), 34; George Bradburn, A Memorial of George Bradburn, comp. Frances H. Bradburn (Boston, 1883).
(who is not yet fully prepared to become a non-resistant) followed me in a brief but ingenious speech, rather for the sake of starting difficulties that they might be answered, and of presenting the opposite side of the question that the discussion might not flag, than of assailing the principles of peace. He was succeeded by Frederick Douglass, who displayed the power of an unsophisticated mind and the glow of an earnest heart, in support of the resolution. How charming, how powerful is truth, uttered in love, and clothed with simplicity! His remarks were exceedingly pertinent, and made a visible impression on the countenances of the audience. A very worthy citizen of the place said he wished to suppose a case, in order to test the non-resistance principle. In his opinion, it was a strong case, and went to show the unsoundness of that principle.
'Suppose I am the captain of a large merchant-ship, which sails from Boston for a foreign port, having on board, in addition to the crew, a large number of passengers, and a very valuable cargo. Suppose, in the course of the voyage, a vessel is seen bearing down on the ship, with the well-known flag of the pirate at its mast-head. Suppose destruction to all on board the ship is inevitable, unless resistance is made with deadly weapons; but, by killing a few of the pirates, it is certain that they may be beaten off without loss to any on board of the ship, and thus a large number of valuable lives and a rich cargo be saved; would it be wrong thus to act on the defensive?'
To this, the reply was—
1. That, though consequences are wrapped up in principle, and are safely provided for in its adoption, yet the only question to be settled is, not what may be the consequences of an act, but whether that act be in accordance with the command of God; for it is not lawful to do evil, that good may come, or to tell a lie even to save the whole human race from destruction. Right action can never be productive of evil consequences.
2. That the only reason why the lives on board the merchant-ship would be jeoparded, in the case supposed, grew out of the ferocious determination of the pirates ! They acted on the law of violence, and not on the law of love. It was not lawful for Christians to wield the weapons of pirates, even to save their own lives.
3. That the non-resistance principle could justly be held responsible only for such consequences as legitimately ensued from its adoption. Now, it would not be pretended that, if all mankind were non-resistants, there would be any pirates on the ocean, or any ruffians on the land, to endanger life; for there would be none to molest or make afraid. The fact, that but a very small portion of mankind were willing to become non-resistants, was no argument against the doctrine; any more than was the fact, that few were disposed to live soberly and righteously in this evil world, an argument against the duty of all men to follow Christ. They who were for killing their enemies, for self-preservation, must, therefore, be held responsible for all the piracies that were committed on the great deep, and not they who were the advocates of non-resistance.
4. The loss of thousands of lives, in yielding obedience to God, would prove no calamity either to the victims or to the world; nor was it to be presented as a sound reason for abandoning the path of duty in any emergency, however seemingly frightful. 'Duty is urs, consequences are God's.'
5. If Christ willingly laid down his life for his murderers, and refused to defend himself, (though he had all power to do so,) they who had the spirit of Christ would joyfully imitate his example, whenever reduced to a similar extremity.
6. In the service of Satan, men could be hired for a few shillings a day to be shot at like dogs, and could boldly march up to the cannon's mouth, and mount 'the deadly imminent breach,' at once courting and despising death. Were the followers of Christ to be less courageous and self-sacrificing in his service, knowing that they were to reign with him in glory? Why, then, tell of the arising from christian obedience?
7. In the case supposed, it must be taken for granted, that all on board of the ship were Christians; for the only point at issue was, how,, should they receive the pirates. Now, in order to know whether they could kill any of these pirates, it was necessary to know what weapons they could properly have in their possession, as the subjects of Christ's kingdom. [See II. Corinthians, x. 3, 4. 5.] They were . If, then, they could defend themselves, and destroy their assailants, with weapons, they had a right to wield them, in the name of the Lord! As to the nature of that kingdom, reference was made to John xxiii. 36. Again—the military equipments, for such an emergency, might be found accurately enumerated in Ephesians, vi. 10 to 19. Finally, Christ had enjoined it upon his disciples, to be harmless as doves, and to be as sheep in the midst of wolves. It was certainly lawful for sheep, in case a troop of wolves was hastening to devour them,—and for doves, in order to protect themselves from a swarm of ravening eagles,—to destroy one or more of their assailants, But, the question was, how they would be able to do it? And when was such an event ever known?
It is worthy of remark, in this connection, that individuals differ very widely in regard to the peculiar objects of their aversion. This often depends on their profession or employment. A large portion of the male inhabitants of the Cape are mariners, and in numerous instances commandersof packets, from the leviathan ship to the tiny sloop. Now, seamen have usually a great dread of pirates; and it was quite natural, therefore, that the case of a piratical attack should be instanced, in order to present the non-resistance doctrine under peculiarly thrilling circumstances. But that doctrine is not to be repudiated as untenable in any case; for it is of heaven, not of men, and it is not in the power of pirates or devils to prove its falsity by their infernal deeds.
Henry C. WrightWright, Henry Clarke
Abolitionist and pacifist Henry Clarke Wright (1797-1870) was one of Garrison's close associates. Reared in central New York, Wright served an apprenticeship as a hatmaker before studying at Andover Theological Seminary. In 1835 he joined the American Anti-Slavery Society and served as one of Theodore Dwight Weld's "seventy agents" until the executive board of the American Anti-Slavery Society removed him in 1837 because of his ultraist opinions. At about the same time he gave up his lecturing agency in the American Peace Society, which was also discomfited by his radicalism, and in 1838 helped found the New England Non-Resistance Society. Nonresistance, the foundation of Wright's reform philosophy, proclaimed the sovereignty of individual conscience and opposed all forms of coercion, violence, and the dominion of man over man. In theory Wright condoned violent resistance to slavery, though he personally eschewed violence. From 1842 to 1847 he traveled in Europe, lecturing on nonresistance and abolitionism. His avowal of antisabbatarian views in Scotland and his accusations (later retracted) that Free Churchmen were "drunkards" made Douglass chary of him. "Friend Wright has created against himself prejudices which I as an abolitionist do not feel myself called upon to withstand," Douglass wrote. Wright later turned to spiritualism and helped organize the Universal Peace Union in 1867. He died in Pawtucket, Rhode Island. Douglass to Richard D. Webb, 10 November 1845, Anti-Slavery Collection, MB; Henry C. Wright to Douglass, 12 December 1846, in Lib., 29 January 1847; Henry C. Wright, Human Life: Illustrated in My Individual Experience as a Child, a Youth, and a Man (Boston, 1849); Peter Brock, Pacifism in the United Stales: From the Colonial Era to the First World War (Princeton, N.J., 1968), 516-18, 532-600, 926-27; Perry, Radical Abolitionism, 18-22, 60-61, 89-90, 159, 222-29, 234-38, 262, 278-82; ACAB, 6:623; NCAB, 2:232.
happily arrived in season to participate in the discussion at the evening meeting, and made a long and powerful speech against the life-taking principle. Some excellent remarks were also made, on the same side, by Elkanah NickersonNickerson, Elkanah
, a most worthy and devoted advocate of Christian liberty and peace—one of those who have been stigmatized by priestly scorners as '.' Regarding the source whence the term originated, it is a most honorable appellation, from bearing which let none shrink who feel that they are worthy of it. The true disciples of Christ are all 'Come-outers.' They have from a kingdom of darkness, violence and blood—from a soul destroying priesthood—from an apostate church—from a spurious religion—from all the works of the devil. Their example is fast becoming contagious, and may it be speedily imitated all over the world, that Christ, the Prince of Peace, may reign from sea to sea, and from the rising to the going down of the sun!
I observed, at the evening service, a person in one corner of the house, of princely bearing and a martial air, listening apparently with great interest, and behaving in a most exemplary manner. I was afterwards informed that it was Commodore SwainSwain, Commodore
, formerly of Nantucket, who had been employed in the Mexican service, and was expecting to enter that service again. He remained nearly to the close of the meeting; and though a steady and tremendous battery was opened against the war system, and against all its advocates and abettors, he never flinched, nor manifested any symptom of anger or impatience, but exhibited rare fortitude and admirable magnanimity. I regret that he did not feel disposed to present his side of the question, for the meeting was open to all. I look for the conversion of such a man to the pacific principles of the gospel much sooner than I do for that of any Reverend Doctor of Divinity; though, for aught that I know, the Commodore may at the present time be a scoffer at the christian faith, and persuaded in his own mind that all religion is a cheat. May he learn to discern and separate the precious from the vile, and be eager to put it on the whole armor of God, and fight valiantly in the cause of righteousness!
The remainder of this sketch will be given in the next paper.
